Key result
Surgeon experience with penetrating cardiac injury linked to ~5-fold higher survival versus first-time operators.
Why the study?
Penetrating cardiac injuries are rare with high mortality, and factors affecting outcomes including surgeon experience need analysis.
What are the characteristics and factors affecting outcomes in patients with penetrating cardiac injury?
Cohort (n=23)
No
What are the characteristics and factors affecting outcomes in patients with penetrating cardiac injury?
Absolute Event Rate: 75% vs 14.3%
p-value: p=0.01
Surgeon experience is a key prognostic factor in the high-mortality setting of penetrating cardiac injuries.
Surgeon experience may affect survival in penetrating cardiac injury; hypothesis-generating from Level 5 data and needs prospective validation.
BACKGROUND: Penetrating cardiac injuries are rare but represent a high mortality. Early recognition of the injury and rapid intervention are necessary. We analyzed the characteristics of patients with penetrating injury and the factors affecting the outcome, including the experience of the general surgeon. METHODS: Twenty-three patients suffering penetrating cardiac injury were retrospectively evaluated in the Istanbul Okmeydanı Training and Research Hospital, Department of General Surgery between 1995 and 2009. Patients with no sign of life on admission were excluded. RESULTS: All patients were male, and the median age was 25 years. Fifteen patients had left ventricular, 4 had right ventricular and 4 had right atrial injuries; in addition, 2 patients had accompanying intra-abdominal injuries. No coronary vascular injury was reported, and pericardial tamponade did not statistically influence the outcome. Ten of 23 patients suffering of penetrating cardiac injury were lost, and in 6 of the 10 cases, the patient represented the first experience for the operating surgeon. CONCLUSION: The characteristics of the penetrating cardiac injuries seen in our institution are consistent with the literature. However, we believe that the surgeon's experience is another prognostic factor. Dedicated level 1 emergency services and trained trauma surgeons are invaluable.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Kamalı et al. (2011) conducted a cohort in Penetrating cardiac injury (n=23). Surgeon's previous operative experience with cardiac injuries vs. Surgeons with no previous experience (first case) was evaluated on Survival (p=0.01). Survival following penetrating cardiac injury was significantly higher when patients were operated on by surgeons with previous cardiac injury experience (75%) compared to those operated on by surgeons facing their first case (14.3%).
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: