Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The study investigated the influence of harrowing intensity on segetal flora diversity and yield parameters via literature review (1990–2022), a questionnaire with 21 organic farmers, and in field trials in winter wheat with different harrowing treatments (2018–2020, federal state Brandenburg). In the literature review, seven studies with 42 comparison pairs were identified. Harrowing had a stronger effect on segetal flora density (number of individuals) in winter (-60.4%) than in spring cereals (-42.0%). The influence on crop yield ranged from -1.6% (median) in winter crops to 0.5% in summer crops. Harrowing once reduced segetal density by 23%, while more frequent harrowing led to a reduction of 57.7%. The results of the questionnaire indicated that nearly three-quarters of the farmers did not harrow certain crops at all. More than two-thirds harrowed winter spelt, winter wheat and field beans up to three times. The field trial identified 41 segetal taxa. The coverage differed between 5 and 25%, while a significant reduction was determined by harrowing four times. The harrowing intensities did not show significant effects on species’ richness and yield parameters, however, the mean number of segetal species was significantly reduced by harrowing two to four times. Overall, the results show that increased harrowing intensity reduces segetal growth moderately with only minimal effects on yield. Regarding the positive services of segetal flora, e.g. for pollinators, farmers should carefully balance the trade-offs between harrowing operations, yield and flora diversity. More studies are necessary to highlight the complex interactions of these issues in different regions.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Stein-Bachinger et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: