Key result
L-NMMA blunts preload increase by ~60% and decreases stroke dimension more than phenylephrine in dogs.
Why the study?
The nitric oxide synthase inhibitor L-NMMA causes reductions in cardiac output that exceed those from phenylephrine at matched systemic arterial pressure, and the mechanisms underlying this difference were unclear.
Does L-NMMA cause a greater reduction in cardiac output compared to phenylephrine due to differences in preload in healthy dogs?
RCT (n=8)
Random
Does L-NMMA cause a greater reduction in cardiac output compared to phenylephrine due to differences in preload in healthy dogs?
Absolute Event Rate: 3.8% vs 9.6%
p-value: p=< .05
The greater reduction in cardiac output caused by L-NMMA compared to phenylephrine is primarily attributable to a lesser increase in preload, highlighting the importance of variable venular versus arteriolar constrictor effects.
Differential venular effects may explain preload and stroke dimension differences; hypothesis-generating for vasopressor selection in shock.
OBJECTIVE: The nitric oxide synthase inhibitor L-N(G)-methylarginine hydrochloride (L-NMMA HC1 546C88) causes reductions in cardiac output (CO), a potential limitation to clinical application. This drop in CO exceeds that from phenylephrine at matched systemic arterial pressure. We tested the hypothesis that the greater fall in CO attributable to L-NMMA primarily reflects a difference in venoconstriction between agents, such that phenylephrine produces larger increases in preload (an independent determinant of CO). DESIGN: Random infusion of phenylephrine or L-NMMA. SETTING: An animal research laboratory. SUBJECTS: Eight healthy, conscious, male dogs. INTERVENTIONS: L-N(G)-methylarginine hydrochloride (20 mg/kg for 1 hr) and phenylephrine (0.5 to 3 microg/kg/min) were administered into eight dogs chronically instrumented to measure left ventricular pressure and dimension. Data were measured at a constant heart rate (140 beats/min) to render CO proportional to stroke dimension. MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS: At a matched increase in afterload (effective arterial elastance), L-NMMA increased preload (end-diastolic dimension) to a lesser degree (3.8%+/-1.5%, p < .05) than phenylephrine (9.6%+/-1.6%, p < .05 vs. L-NMMA). Neither L-NMMA nor phenylephrine affected the slope of the end-systolic pressure dimension relationship, although L-NMMA shifted the relationship rightward (1.7+/-0.7 mm, p < .05), consistent with a mild negative inotropic effect. L-NMMA decreased the stroke dimension to a greater extent than phenylephrine (-24.1%+/-6.8% and -10.6%+/-3.4%, respectively, p < .05). CONCLUSIONS: Differential CO responses to phenylephrine and L-NMMA were primarily attributable to changes in preload. Variable venular vs. arteriolar constrictor effects must be considered when evaluating the integrated cardiovascular response to a vasoactive agent.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Harrison et al. (2000) conducted an RCT in Healthy dogs (n=8). L-N(G)-methylarginine hydrochloride (L-NMMA) vs. Phenylephrine (0.5 to 3 microg/kg/min) was evaluated on Increase in preload (end-diastolic dimension) at a matched increase in afterload (p=< .05). L-NMMA increased preload to a lesser degree (3.8% vs 9.6%, p<0.05) and decreased stroke dimension more (-24.1% vs -10.6%, p<0.05) than phenylephrine at matched afterload in dogs.
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: