Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Belowground carbon allocation regulates soil carbon inputs and ecosystem resilience, yet global evidence for how management alters allocation across resource gradients remains limited. I used a global terrestrial net primary production archive to test whether human management changes the fraction of total net primary production allocated belowground and whether that effect is comparable to climatic and edaphic controls on total net primary production. I aggregated repeated field measurements to site means across 456 terrestrial sites spanning forests, grasslands, peatlands, shrublands, tundra, and croplands, calculated belowground production fractions for 293 sites, and fitted weighted least-squares models that incorporated archived methodological uncertainty. Unmanaged grasslands allocated substantially more production belowground than managed grasslands (median difference = 0.182, 95% confidence interval 0.097–0.238, $$p < 0.001$$ p < 0.001 ), whereas forests showed no detectable management contrast (median difference = 0.003, 95% confidence interval $$-0.057$$ - 0.057 to 0.059, $$p = 0.967$$ p = 0.967 ). In the final allocation model, the unmanaged-by-open-ecosystem interaction was positive (estimate = 0.154, 95% confidence interval 0.054 to 0.254, $$p = 0.003$$ p = 0.003 ), and cross-validated R² R 2 increased from 0.160 in the climate baseline to 0.243. For total net primary production, climate and resource covariates improved cross-validated R² R 2 from 0.223 to 0.269, with positive effects of annual mean temperature, aridity index, and atmospheric nitrogen deposition, whereas the management term weakened in the conservative subset excluding croplands and treatment experiments. These results show that management more strongly reorganizes carbon allocation than total productivity, especially in open ecosystems, providing a field-based benchmark for ecosystem science and model evaluation.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Gianmarco Goycochea Casas (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: