Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Where Are We Now? Septic ankle arthritis can be successfully treated with a combination of surgery and antibiotics, but this approach does not always work. Despite the ability of patients to connect with physicians’ offices in near-instantaneous fashion through electronic means (which facilitates prompt diagnoses) and ongoing efforts to develop better antibiotics, prompt surgical intervention, and aggressive debridements, some of these infections persist, and both the infections and complications arising from treating them are increasing in number. Up to 10 million people may die annually because of bacterial resistance alone [3]. With an increasing number of surgical procedures performed on the ankle, infections will inevitably develop in more people [7]. Will we see increasing morbidity and a higher number of amputations because of this? Or will we be able to control this problem? External fixation is generally viewed as the go-to procedure for an infected joint or long bone. The advantages are that infected hardware in the surgical site is removed, the desired level of compression across the joint or fracture site can be achieved, and pins are placed in infection-free zones. However, this procedure has been associated with a number of complications, including pin tract infections, osteomyelitis, frame loosening, malunion, nonunion, neurovascular injury, and compartment syndrome [4]. In patients with irreversible ankle destruction caused by bacterial infection, Wang et al. [9] demonstrated that the treatment of symptomatic septic ankle arthritis with extensive joint debridement, excision of infected and necrotic tissues, complete synovectomy, hardware removal, and external fixation results in successful fusion 96% of the time. These patients demonstrated improvements in not only pain but also function. Unfortunately, about 30% of the patients treated this way experienced complications, and these patients had to wear an external fixator for an average of 6 months. To preserve the ankle’s structure and function and avoid the sequelae of ankle arthrodesis (which includes progressive subtalar joint arthritis), all efforts should be made to eradicate infection with immediate arthroscopic or open joint debridement. However, based on this study’s results in this subset of patients with irreversible ankle destruction caused by sepsis, I believe that surgeons should universally attempt limb salvage. Where Do We Need To Go? The results of this study [9] are staggering in two ways: The success of this procedure is impressive, yet the morbidity is disappointingly high. How can we achieve fusion in all (or nearly all) of our patients while simultaneously eradicating infection and maintaining good function with very little morbidity? Pin tract infections, which can occur up to 75% of the time, need to be a focus of our attention [9]. Nonunions, which occurred in 9% of patients in this study [9], must be minimized. The duration the external fixator is worn, which was an average of 6 months in this study, should also be reduced, if possible. The morbidity after wearing external fixators is considerable. Six months is a long period to endure an external fixator; some patients experience very real psychologic problems associated with having to wear one. These include hostility, anxiety, and depression in patients, not only while wearing the external fixator, but also after it has been removed [1]. The direction in which we need to go is clear: We need to reduce the major surgical and psychologic complications associated with the tools we have at hand. How Do We Get There? These problems can be addressed by considering the use of emerging technology. Pin tract infections can be eliminated by minimizing the time the external fixator is worn. One method is to consider hybrid treatment. This begins with initial external fixator placement, evaluation of the eradication of infection by serologic and radiographic analysis, and conversion to internal fixation as soon as possible. Special bacteria-resistant coatings placed on the implant may minimize the recurrence of infection. Direct implant coatings include silver ions bonded to the metallic surface [2]. Silver is believed to have a low risk of resistance, and it can function against multidrug-resistant gram-positive and gram-negative bacteria as a bacteriostatic or bactericidal agent, depending on the concentration of silver ions [8]. Although these types of implants are not widely available, a reduction in infection has been demonstrated in a study of silver-coated tumor megaprostheses [6]. Silver is just one of several bacteria-resistant coatings being studied in humans. An additional consideration is the use of an internal implant that can dynamically compress an arthrodesis site, much like an external fixator does. One such material is Nitinol, which exhibits sustained dynamic internal compression while at body temperature. The use of a retrograde Nitinol intramedullary hindfoot nail has been shown to be more likely to achieve fusion than was a non-Nitinol intramedullary static nail [5]. Future studies will be needed to verify this, but I believe a Nitinol nail can decrease morbidity related to the external fixator’s wires. I believe it would be possible to perform a follow-up study similar to the one in this month’s CORR® [9], performed in staged fashion with a hybrid technique using antimicrobial implants that provide dynamic internal compression. I think it’s likely this approach would show a reduction in surgical complications, improved psychologic responses (which is an endpoint I hope these future studies might evaluate), and a higher likelihood of achieving fusion. Implementation of emerging technologies can help keep us one step ahead of the microorganism in the treatment of septic ankle arthritis.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Christopher B. Hirose (2022) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: