This is the authors' abstract. We don't add key points for this paper.
We are grateful for Keevil’s (2020) identification of a mistakenly limited prior in the code we supplied as a supplement to Reinke et al. (2020), describing a new model. Within our paper, we demonstrated use of a hierarchical model using mark–recapture datasets that were also published as supplementary material. The introduction of the model was the focus of our paper and the code was included as a courtesy to those who would like to use the model, with parameters adjusted to suit their needs. This transparency allowed Keevil (2020) to run our model with the provided example datasets, identify the limited prior, and set values of their choosing. We are therefore pleased to see firsthand the benefits of open access in science. Gompertz model Ux = Aebx Data through 2015 – Female (N = 1,031) (Warner et al. 2016) To summarize our three points in opposition to the critique of Warner et al. (2016): growing databases will result in parameter estimate variation – one hopes in the direction of the true parameter value – but changes nonetheless; intraspecific variation in rates of aging are common with results from one population not necessarily dictating a value representative of all populations of a species; and, using the same Bayesian framework as used in our earlier publication, we reaffirm that mortality senescence can be measured in this population of painted turtles. We end by recommending that a more productive consideration is the interpretation of aging rates. Whether turtles age very slowly, not at all, or slowly increase survival with age, what are the biological ramifications of such findings? As was argued in Warner et al. (2016), turtle aging is much slower than seen in mammals of similar body size. The point at which extremely slow positive or negative aging can be considered to be negligible is an interesting and open question. When considered in a broad comparative context, future studies that contrast turtles as a monophyletic group versus other such groups will help to resolve this question. Code and data examples were published with the original Statistical Report as Supplemental Information (Reinke et al. 2020): https://doi.org/10.1002/ecy.2877
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Bronikowski et al. (2021) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: