Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The direct comparisons tailored to channel-type waste dumps are scarce, which leaves engineers without evidence-based guidance on when a screening estimate is sufficient and when a higher-fidelity simulation is needed. This study assesses the runout distance of a channel-type waste dump in the Panxi region (SW China) under an extreme-rainfall scenario by combining an Energy Conservation Method (ECM) screening model with a Depth-Integrated Continuum Method (DICM) simulation. By comparing predicted runout distances and examining the influence of channel geometry on flow routing, we propose a tiered, cross-model triangulation workflow for risk assessment of similar dumps. For a plausible 5,280 m³ local failure, ECM predicts a screening runout distance of S = 378.72 m. The DICM simulation re-solves a 350 s dynamic process with distinct initiation, propagation and deposition phases, yielding a peak velocity of 8.54 m/s and a final runout of S = 354 m. Relative to the downstream residential receptor at LR = 430 m, both methods indicate no direct inundation but a near-miss, with impact margins (LR − S) of 51 m (ECM) and 76 m (DICM). The two runout estimates differ by <8%. The results support a two-tier, dual-method workflow in which ECM provides rapid conservative screening, while DICM provides process-based routing and intensity fields for design-level evaluation and receptor-based risk screening in similar engineering contexts.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Zhao et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: