Key result
Caffeine plus placebo expectation improves vigilance and cognitive performance during sleep deprivation versus placebo alone.
Why the study?
Caffeine placebo expectation appears to improve vigilance and cognitive performance, but its effects during prolonged sleep deprivation were unclear.
Does caffeine combined with placebo expectation improve vigilance and cognitive performance in healthy males during sleep deprivation?
RCT (n=10)
Double-blind
Does caffeine combined with placebo expectation improve vigilance and cognitive performance in healthy males during sleep deprivation?
p-value: p=<0.05
The combination of caffeine and placebo expectation exerts prolonged positive effects on vigilance and cognitive performance during sleep deprivation, comparable to a second dose of caffeine.
May inform fatigue management in operational settings; extends RCT evidence on expectation-augmented caffeine effects.
Caffeine placebo expectation seems to improve vigilance and cognitive performance. This study investigated the effect of caffeine and placebo expectation on vigilance and cognitive performance during 28 h sleep deprivation. Ten healthy males volunteered to take part in the double-blind, cross-over study, which required participants to complete five treatment periods of 28 h separated by 1-week wash-out intervals. The treatments were no substance (Control); caffeine 200 mg at 00:00 (C200); placebo 200 mg at 00:00 (P200); twice caffeine 200 mg at 00:00 and 04:00 (C200-C200); caffeine 200 mg at 00:00 and placebo 200 mg at 04:00 (C200-P200). Participants were told that all capsules were caffeine and given information about the effects of caffeine to increase expectation. Vigilance was assessed by a three-letter cancellation test, cognitive functions by the continuous addition test and Stroop test, and cardiovascular regulation by heart rate and blood pressure. Tests were performed bihourly from 00:00 to 10:00 of the second day. Results indicated that C200-P200 and C200-C200 were more alert (p < .05) than Control and P200. Their cognitive functions were higher (p < .05) than Control and P200. Also, C200-P200 scored higher than C200 in the letter cancellation task (p < .05). No test showed any significant differences between C200-P200 and C200-C200. The results demonstrated that the combination of caffeine 200 mg and placebo 200 mg expectation exerted prolonged positive effects on vigilance and cognitive performance.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Sun et al. (2007) conducted an RCT in Sleep deprivation (n=10). Caffeine and placebo expectation vs. No substance (Control) or placebo 200 mg was evaluated on Vigilance and cognitive performance (p=<0.05). Caffeine 200 mg combined with placebo 200 mg expectation improved vigilance and cognitive performance during 28-hour sleep deprivation compared to control and placebo alone (p < 0.05).
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: