Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Background: The undiscerning canon characteristic of minimally invasive thoracic surgery (MITS) is challenged from an unorthodox subjective viewpoint of an academic thoracic surgeon highly experienced in MITS and optimally invasive thoracic surgery alike with extensive relevant literature output. Methods: A staging historical review of milestones of MITS is complemented by a subjective and arbitrary list of contemporary clinical questions regarding overextension of minimal invasiveness in thoracic surgery. Subsequent generations of surgeons and their surgical preferences are compared and dissected. The attitude of the surgical community towards stapler failures is questioned. Emerging dogmas concerning ideal and exclusive interventions for pneumothorax and inflammatory lung conditions are exposed. Results: The historical analysis concludes in a three stages concept in the form of a skeletal framework. Stage I represents the pre-video enhanced surgery age lasting up through 1990 ca. Stage II consists of echelon 1 [prior to 2000] echelon 2 [2000–2010] and echelon 3 up through today. Stage III is yet ahead of us outfitted with resplendent adornments including remote controlled intracavitary tools supported by integrative image guidance. Non-stapled tissue fusion methods are to be game changers. Crucial components of the operative interactions undoubtedly need scrutiny. Focused cases of the surgeon, the stapler and the video-assisted thoracic surgery (VATS) procedures themselves are investigated including elements of mythology hovering over MITS and are dissected to the bones. Conclusions: Surgical technique questions such as open thoracotomy procedure or MITS methods should be a matter of pure scientific and clinical consideration definitely not a sort of quasi religious conviction. Instead of minimizing surgical invasivity uncritically, optimization of surgical aggressivity is called for, in which operative technology plays an unquestionable crucial role, however its application cannot eclipse or even blur the ultimate aim of surgery: its benefit to the individual patient while serving the larger community—namely society.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Tamás F. Molnár (2023) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: