Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
IN radiation therapy it would be obviously of great advantage to choose a unit of dose such that the same biological effect would be produced by a given dose, irrespective of the quality, or even kind, of radiation employed, provided, of course, that all other conditions remained the same. There is enough experimental evidence available to-day to prove that this ideal situation cannot be realized by the adoption of anyone unit of dose, in the quality range which includes both ordinary x-rays and gamma rays. It becomes necessary, therefore, to examine the problem with the object of selecting a unit which approaches the ideal one as closely as our present knowledge permits. Taking for granted the existence of a difference in biological effect produced by radiation of different wave length (irrespective of the unit of dosage) the quasi-ideal unit would be one which makes possible the specification of equivalent biological effect by the smallest number of dosage factors. The smallest possible number in which such a “biological dose” may be expressed, is two: one representing the quantity factor of the dose, and the other the quality factor, both referring to the point at which the biological effect is produced. By these two factors one must be able to express doses of (ionizing) radiation of any wave length, which are biologically equivalent, when all other conditions are identical. Biological equivalence in this connection must necessarily mean equivalence in the degree of effect produced. If the kind of effect is different, no comparison at all is possible. In the ordinary therapeutic range of wave lengths, it may be assumed that there is an equivalence in kind. That is, erythema, tumor regression, and a host of other biological effects, are all produced by radiation of widely different wave lengths, irrespective of any possible differences in the mechanism by which these biological changes are brought about. The biological dose, Db, may be expressed as follows: Db = D q b, where D = Dose, or quantity factor, which can be measured and expressed in suitable units. q = Quality factor, representing the biological effectiveness of radiation with respect to wave length. b is a factor depending on all other conditions—largely biological—which are assumed to remain constant, when the influence of wave length is being investigated. (Therefore it can be taken as unity in the present case.) We shall now inquire how the dose D should be measured and in what unit it should be expressed in order that the quality factor q shall depend only on the wave length of the radiation, as it should when all other conditions are constant. It has been stated many times, and it is obvious, that the part of the radiation which is responsible for the biological effect is that which is “absorbed” by the living organism. In the case of ionizing radiation, not all the absorbed energy manifests itself in the form of ionization, but the ratio between the total absorbed energy and that which is utilized in forming ions is, so far as we know, substantially independent of the wave length, in the present therapeutic range. Thus, since the two are related by a proportionality factor, one may take ionization as a measure of energy absorbed. This refers, of course, to the ionization produced in the living material, at the point where the biological change takes place.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
G. Failla (1937) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: