Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
most have been imposed by state legislatures, governors, state departments of education, and even local governing boards without input from those who do the work. Often, the assumptions that provide the foundation for these reform efforts are murky, lack research, or simply express a desire by some politician(s) to carry out an agenda that can be fulfilled only by reforming the system. To a large extent, the charter movement falls into the latter category. Incredibly, millions of public dollars are being pumped into the charter school movement based on implicit and unstudied assumptions. In their book The Manufactured Crisis (1995), Berliner and Biddle point out that the debate to create and support charter schools comes largely from legislators who ignore the success of public schools in the last 25 years and who are simultaneously reluctant to allocate adequate funds to allow schools the opportunity to be successful. Ironically, charter schools are formed around a narrower mission and have freedom from excess regulations while public schools are expected to teach a burgeoning curriculum often expanded by state or federal mandates required by the same legislators who now promote charter schools as a reform. Recent survey results indicate that 20 states have some form of charter legislation (Mulholland & Amsler, 1992) resulting in approximately 250 schools with charter status. The number of charter
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Garcia et al. (1996) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: