Key result
Invasive procedures linked to a ~254% higher adverse event rate versus no invasive procedures.
Why the study?
Retrospective case record analysis underestimates the true rate of adverse events in surgical patients due to omission bias, necessitating prospective surveillance for accurate assessment.
Does continuous enhanced prospective surveillance detect a high rate of adverse events in general surgery patients?
Observational (n=113)
No
Does continuous enhanced prospective surveillance detect a high rate of adverse events in general surgery patients?
Continuous enhanced prospective surveillance reveals a high rate of adverse events in surgical patients, particularly those undergoing invasive procedures, suggesting it is more sensitive than retrospective review.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
May warrant closer monitoring for invasive procedures in surgery; leaves open whether enhanced prospective surveillance improves detection or outcomes.
Introduction: Retrospective case record analysis indicates that 3% to 17% of hospital inpatients experience harm from their management, surgical patients being particularly at risk. Retrospective record analysis is prone to omission bias, leading to an unknown degree of inaccuracy. Aims: We aimed to determine the true rate of adverse events in surgical patients by continuous enhanced prospective surveillance and independent analysis by experienced surgeons. Methods: Admissions to a surgical ward for a single month were prospectively studied, matching their clinical course against staff expectations. An experienced surgeon identified unexpected events and classified them as potentially or actually adverse or not. Three independent consultant surgeons validated these findings and evaluated the preventability of adverse events. Results: One hundred thirteen patients were studied: 84 (74%) were emergencies, and 29 (26%) were elective admissions; 61 patients (54%) underwent an invasive procedure. There were 52 adverse or potentially adverse events in 45 patients (40%). Twenty-nine adverse events occurred in 26 patients (23%), of which, 8 were considered preventable. Invasive procedures were associated with adverse events (34% versus 9.6%; χ21 = 14.52; P = 0.0004), but no difference was observed between emergency and elective admissions (25% versus 24%). There was no significant difference in risk between patients older and younger than 70 years (24% versus 23%; χ21 = 0.686; P > 0.25). Conclusions: Continuous enhanced prospective surveillance revealed an unexpectedly high rate of potential and actual adverse events among surgical patients, especially in association with invasive maneuvers. This method may be more sensitive than case record review and detects a clinically relevant set of events.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Kaul et al. (2007) conducted an observational in General surgery admissions (n=113). Invasive procedures vs. No invasive procedure was evaluated on Adverse events (p=0.0004). Invasive procedures in surgical patients were associated with a higher rate of adverse events compared to no invasive procedures.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: