Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Senior Associate in Anesthesia; Associate Professor of Anaesthesia.In the days when no anesthetics were known, when the wounded or diseased must suffer the tortures of amputation, or the rough operations known in those days, with no relief till sheer pain should either kill or produce unconsciousness - here was a plant whose wonderful properties alone had the gift of showing mercy! Here was the ancient anaesthetic of the world, probably discovered by chance by the very witches who dropped its root into their bubbling pots for wicked incantation, and perhaps fell asleep as they inhaled its fumes or partook of their own magic potions. Here was a discovery indeed![1]ANESTHESIOLOGISTS are familiar, at least historically, with the technique of “twilight sleep” used at the beginning of the 20th century, but the current use of anticholinergic agents as antagonists of the side effects of anesthetic and anticholinesterase agents is much more familiar. There was a time, however, when the botanical precursors of these modern drugs, Atropa mandragora (A. mandragora) and Atropa belladonna (A. belladonna), were the state of the art in pain relief. Alone, or in combination with other atropine-containing herbals such as henbane (Hyoscyamus niger) or hemlock (Conium), they were used as anodyne, soporific, and hallucinogenic agents. This article examines the medical use of these naturally occurring anticholinergic agents from ancient to modern times.A. mandragora (also called love apple, devil's apple, mandrake, or mandragora officinarum), native to the Mediterranean and southern Europe, is a common plant throughout the Middle East. Atropa, found in the words atropine, Atropa mandragora, and Atropa belladonna, is derived from Atropos, the eldest of the Fates, whose duty it was to cut the thread of life [2,3](Figure 1). [4,5]The derivation of the words mandragora and mandrake is less uncertain. The words may be a variation of the Greek Mandragoritis, an alternate name for Venus, or a compound of the Sanskrit mandros (sleep) and agora (object or substance). That the Greeks were acquainted with the dangerous properties of the A. mandragora root was shown by an alternate name, Circeium, derived from Circe, the sorceress who changed Odysseus's men into swine and who was celebrated for her knowledge of magic and venomous herbs.A. belladonna (also called belladonna, deadly nightshade, or witch's berry), from which atropine (dl-hyoscyamine) and scopolamine (l-hyoscine) are derived, also was associated with Hecate, the Greek goddess of the underworld, night, and witchcraft. The term belladonna is typically translated as beautiful lady, as originally mentioned by Mattioli in 1554. Commonly thought to have been used as a cosmetic, a mydriatic, and an aphrodisiac agent in the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries, there is little evidence of the use of belladonna as a cosmetic anywhere other than Venice. In old Italian, donna is more properly translated as mistress or lady. The bella donna may have been a magical or beautiful lady (or spirit) of the forest, and the term may have been used euphemistically as a substitute for witch, suggesting an association with potions and herbalism. In the late Medieval period, servants too poor to have access to real doctors had to satisfy themselves with the potions prepared by a magician or witch, the buona donna. [6]Theophrastus (370–285 before the common era [BCE]), a student of Plato (ca. 428–348 BCE) and Aristotle (384–322 BCE), classified plants and noted their medicinal properties. In contrast to earlier Egyptian, Chinese, and Indian writings that described combinations of plants or remedies with a single name, Theophrastus classified and evaluated single plant remedies such as A. mandragora [7]:“The leaf of (mandrake), they say, used with meal, is useful for wounds, and the root for erysipelas, when scraped and steeped in vinegar, and also for gout, for sleeplessness and for love potions.”[8]It is clear that he believed that the leaf and the root of A. mandragora had multiple therapeutic benefits.In conjunction with the administration of mandrake wine, the Greek herbalist Dioscorides (ca. 40–90 of the common era [CE]) used the word anesthesia for the first time:“Using a cyathus[dagger] of it for such as cannot sleep, or are grievously pained, and upon whom being cut, or cauterized they wish to make a not-feeling pain.[double dagger]”[12]Three times in this same passage, Dioscorides pointed out that when physicians are about to cut or burn a patient, they should give him the wine of mandrake to cause insensibility, an idea viewed so positively by subsequent admirers that it seemed nothing short of divinely inspired (Figure 2). [13,14]As a well-traveled military physician, Dioscorides gathered a great deal of information about mandrake, which he recorded in De Materia Medica, including comprehensive descriptions of the preparation, expected benefits and toxic side effects of the plants:Ye juice being drank ye muchness of ye quantity of 2 Oboli [section] with Melicrate, [double vertical bar] doth expel upward Phlegm, and black choler, as Eleebore # doth, but being too much drank it drives out ye life … and being put up into ye seat for a suppository, it causeth sleep … Ye wine of ye bark of ye root is prepared without seething but you must cast in 3 pounds into a Metreta sup ** of sweet wine, and that there be given of it 3 Cyathi to such as shall be cut, or cauterized, as is aforesaid. For they do not apprehend the pain, because they are overborn with dead sleep … but used too much they make men speechless … Physicians also, use this, when they are about to cut, or cauterize. [12]Despite the care Dioscorides took to describe the medicinal uses of plants and to caution the ignorant, expectations of the public also were influenced by those who promoted ritualistic gathering of the plant. One of the most consistent stories used to justify ritualistic mandrake gathering was that of the dreadful shriek the mandrake produced when taken from the earth and the subsequent death of the person who had the presumption to drag the root from its bed. The mandrake, therefore, was obtained by fastening the plant to the tail of a dog, who drew the root from the ground. Theophrastus himself fell victim to this falsehood. He described the special precautions necessary for the collection of the mandrake, such as tracing a circle three times around the plant with a sword and cutting the plant while facing west. Pliny the Elder (23–72 CE) also advised keeping to the windward to avoid the foul stench of the uprooted plant.How effective the ancient anodyne agents were has been a matter of some controversy. If Dioscorides observed the efficacy of such preparations, why were they not used more often? Part of the answer may be embedded in the Hippocratic oath itself, which discouraged the practice of surgery by physicians, including “cutting even for the stone.” The opening of abscesses, the use of cautery, the setting of fractures, and the reduction of dislocations, however, were not considered surgery. Suitable drugs such as alcohol and beer in Pharaonic Egypt, opium imported from Cyprus, and possibly hemp seed (cannabis) were available for producing major pain relief, if not genuine surgical anesthesia, in the second millenium BCE. [10]The Saracens conquered Alexandria in 640 CE. By 711 CE, they were patrons of learning, translating Greek texts, including the ancient herbals, into Syriac and spreading this knowledge throughout the East. Avicenna (Abu Ali Hussain ibn Abdullah ibn Sina, 1980–1037 CE) wrote his Canon of Medicine in the early eleventh century. In it, he recognized the medical usefulness of opium, henbane and mandrake [15]:If it is desirable to procure a deeply unconscious state, so as to enable the pain to be borne … administer fumitory opium, hyoscyamus (half dram dose of each)… Add this to the wine, and take as much as is necessary for the purpose. Or boil black hyoscyamus in water, with mandragora bark, until it becomes red, and then add this to the wine.Western monks collected medicinal recipes and cultivated herbs during the Early Medieval Period (500–950 CE, The Dark Ages). Nonetheless, even as medical studies and practice were becoming more widespread in monastic circles, the Council of Clermont (1130 CE) forbade the practice of medicine by the monks, and the Council of Tours (1163 CE) clarified this proscription with “Ecclesia abhorret a sanguine”("the Church does not shed blood"). The practice of surgery was effectively taken out of the hands of physicians, because most physicians were also members of the clergy. The only exception was in Italy and southern France, where the secular tradition still held, and some physicians continued to practice the art of surgery. [16]They further incorporated into their practice a knowledge of herbalism acquired from Islamic scholars, who preserved such information after the fall of Rome and throughout the Crusades. This information entered Europe principally via Salerno, an important trade center on the southwest coast of Italy. Salerno thus was a geographic, political, and philosophical crossroads for herbal lore from Greco-Roman tradition, monastic medicine, and Jewish-Arabic and Oriental practices of the Middle East and northern Africa. [17]Those who cared for the sick may have had ready access to secular reference works, which were no problem to obtain along the trade routes. [18]It was because of this secular view that surgery could remain within the doctor's purview and include concepts of pain relief and unconsciousness. [17]Practica Chirugiae, written in 1170 CE by the surgeon Roger Frugardi (Roger of Salerno), mentions a sponge soaked in “narcotics” and held to the patient's nose. Hugh of Lucca (ca. 1160–1252 CE) prepared such a sleeping sponge according to a prescription later described by Theodoric of Cervia (ca. 1205–1296 CE) as containing opium, the juice of unripe mulberry, hyoscyamus, spurge flax, leaves of mandragora, ivy, climbing ivy, lettuce seed, lapathum seed, and hemlock. [19]The description of the soporific sponge of Theodoric survived through the Renaissance, largely because of Guy de Chauliac's (1300–1367 CE) The Grand Surgery and the clinical practices of Hans von Gersdorff (c. 1519 CE) and Giambattista della Porta (1535–1615 CE), who used essentially the same formula. The herbalist William Turner (1510–1568 CE) described the “forgetful and sleepish drowsiness” after the ingestion of a potion containing mandragora root and the pragmatic warning “they that smell too much of the apples, become dumb.”[20]The soporific sponge of the Salernitan surgeons and their successors contained varying mixtures of opium (as the primary ingredient) with henbane, nightshade, mandrake, and hemlock as secondary ingredients, but how effective was it? Baur cast doubt on its efficacy in 1972 when she concocted the mixture from locally purchased herbs, moistened a sponge, and found that guinea pigs wound neither become stuporous nor anesthetized when placed on a bell jar with the sponge. [21]In their attempt to study rat responses after duplicating the soporific sponge, Infusino et al. found that only three of five rats became even slightly sedated. [22]Armstrong Davison claimed that the soporific sponge is one of many examples that show how much magic and superstition were a part of therapeutics in the early Middle Ages. [23]The first physician to devote his practice to the administration of anesthetic agents, John Snow (1813–1858 CE), noted that mandrake can cause unconsciousness, especially after intoxication with the drug. [24]Moreover, in 1888 Benjamin Ward Richardson reported his effort at producing mandragora wine, including its lack of efficacy if prepared as a tincture “with strong alcohol.” He noted, however, that “the active principle of mandragora is most soluble in water, as is also the active principle of atropa belladonna,” and went on to state:The effects produced were those of narcotism, dilatation of the pupil, paralysis of motion and sensation, excitement during the stage of recovery, if the dose were not fatal, and sleep and paralysis if the dose were too potent. The action was found to extend to all classes of animals.He specifically reported pigeons and rabbits, and noted that “the heart … continued in action longer than any other part, and indeed, was found to be pulsating after the respiration had for many minutes ceased.” He concluded, “The whole of the facts indeed lead clearly to the acceptance of the belief that the medicinal use of mandragora in ancient times has been correctly recorded. The wine of mandragora is a general anesthetic of the most potent quality.” It also seemed in keeping with contemporaneous medical thought regarding the heart's vital function in survival to believe that the routine use of this preparation would confer protection from the adverse effects of anesthetics because:… from the circumstance that the heart continues to beat after the respiration has ceased, we may infer that as a general anaesthetic the alkaloid might, under necessity, be once more employed, as in the olden time, to deaden the pain of a surgical operation, and that too with comparatively little risk to life. [25]In more recent times, atropine toxicity therapy was used in psychiatric treatment. With a routine dose of 30–50 mg atropine, recovery from coma was noted as “spontaneous and complete in six to nine hours.”[26]Orally administered potions and the soporific sponge were not the only methods of drug delivery. Combined with fats or oils, active ingredients of the plant would penetrate the skin or be absorbed by sweat ducts (in the armpits) or in body orifices (e.g., vagina, rectum). This would allow the psychoactive alkaloid agents, especially hyoscine, access to the blood and brain without passage through the gut. John Arderne (1307–1380 CE) provided eloquent descriptive testimonial to the efficacy of “oyntments”:… the juice of henbane, mandragora, hemlock, lettuce, black and white poppy … with sufficient lard … anoint the forehead, the pulses, the temples, the armpits, the palms of the hands and the soles of the feet and immediately the patient will sleep so soundly that he will not feel any cutting. [27,28]He added advice, however, about appropriate interventions for the recognized risks of such a practice:“And know that it is well to tweak the nose, to pinch the cheeks or to pluck the beard of such a sleeper to quicken his spirits lest he sleep too deeply.”Andres De Laguna (1499–1560 CE), physician to Emperor Charles V and Philip II, provided an unambiguous description of an experiment with an ointment he discovered in the home of a couple accused of witchcraft:… a pot full of a certain green ointment … with which they were annointing themselves … was composed of herbs … such as hemlock, nightshade, henbane, and mandrake … I had the wife of the public executioner annointed with it from head to foot … she … had completely lost power of sleep … no sooner did I annoint her than she opened her eyes, wide like a rabbit, and soon they looked like those of a cooked hare when she fell into such a profound sleep that I thought I should never be able to awake her … after a lapse of thirty-six hours, I restored her to her senses and sanity.This passage is redolent of the description of belladonna alkaloid poisoning “hot as a hare, blind as a bat, dry as a bone, red as a beet, and mad as a wet hen.”[29]De Laguna's personal commentaries accompanying the above text included the astute observation:“From all this we may infer that all that those wretched witches do and say is caused by potions and ointments which so corrupt their memory and their imagination that they create their own woes, for they firmly believe when awake all that they had dreamed when asleep,” making him perhaps the first physician to correlate herbal intoxication with the rituals of witchcraft and to imply that confessions extracted from such drug users might represent the delusional speech of a deranged mind. [30]De Laguna was not the sole commentator about the relationship of mind-altering drugs and witchcraft in the 16th century. In De Praestigiis Daemonum, which Freud called one of the 10 most significant books of all time, Johann Weyer (1515–1588 CE) concluded henbane was a principal ingredient of witches' brew, along with deadly nightshade and mandrake. [31]According to Weyer, there were other ointments, but the essential ingredients remained the same in all. The preparations, when applied to the or were to the of into the of were thought to anoint a or with the devil's and after would through the to for at the CE) observed that the witches themselves are and believe they do which they do not … themselves into other … not by or but by ointments, and annointing themselves all an of plant ointments of the Renaissance, and of witchcraft writings on and the botanical of ointments that witches used on themselves during the and 16th the with of the the reported consistent the of these plants in a was as it would passage of the through the skin and The use of would the passage of because a would be sufficient to the That this is an effective technique may be with who in their the leaves with to There is even evidence for that a was used in these an ointment from the or century, found was to and had an of practices and magical with these descriptions of these was that the mandrake root and The little of the of the mandrake, called and as were to in the of CE) and with who were with the of some was placed would the mandrake was the of a little called or who had to be with of of earlier Greco-Roman the of these plants were to from the of who fell from the that this plant was obtained from the and then only after the risk and and to these of witchcraft and Theophrastus von CE) the of the witches' and probably took of their of all the physician must know are in the and then he must to old to who are called to to and many who are held in CE) in his or of further the mandrake root by that up of this of old or some or I know Turner CE), in to mandrake, wrote that the are and like little and … are nothing but and not used his to for the protection of the the methods of drugs, ye of that and and it was in by no less noted a than William of from whom he may have a great deal about herbalism in for and like out of the that nor mandragora nor all the of the shall medicine to that sweet sleep which of from and available at the beginning of the of the early books were herbals, by who were perhaps influenced by of drugs from a sleep in the setting of medical or surgical was associated with death and discouraged many physicians and from to surgical may for on the part of and the that were used than single remedies either an could have been added or an of effects such as or or such as could have of the surgery or on the anesthetic have in modern times, and we would have no to that the use of herbals such to A. belladonna, this of causeth … it such as have into a many have the (as for modern therapeutic effects and toxicity on a the Greek word drugs and the anesthetic action of the medicinal plants used to a of with opium the most by mandrake, henbane, and hemlock. the of the sixteenth such had largely into If physicians to use herbals in the of the seventeenth century, they were and or for witchcraft. to in the seventeenth and centuries, and at the of these was the of the active ingredients in medicinal The John CE), who that on the of the and thus became the philosophical for the of also observed we know the of the of hemlock, opium and a as a does those of a … we should be able to that will hemlock and opium make a sleep the same time, in trade and was once as at the of the information and drugs through the trade routes. early and the of pain and its to the of herbalism from witchcraft and medicine in the seventeenth his clinical of poisoning in who had hemlock for Johann CE) the toxic effects in of the as and He recorded these including the the of the and the of along with the of either a or of therapeutic efficacy in on on himself and were by CE) of hemlock, and henbane, these were the CE) of with his CE) atropine from belladonna leaves and from in and preparation along with the acceptance of the were with the beginning of and surgical side effects and of anesthetic agents did not as a of his clinical noted the in with and with to the by the and of an In this reported a death of with anesthesia with with that as a of on first might be to the the use of atropine was not until A. CE) of with atropine in with of as the first to administer an of A. belladonna as an In von with and atropine administered to during the of anesthesia, to the of anesthetic drugs, to to and to et the use of anticholinergic drugs in for of as an and anodyne, atropine was into a and for the and of the and a of anesthesia administration of an anesthetic agent without the ready of That the use of the ancient anodyne agents was so by the use of anesthetic agents after has been the of the of and of the century. this of pain relief, no matter the anodyne agents have been ancient or the principle of the thread of life has remained the of anesthetic The of Atropos, the who cut the thread of and her A. mandragora and A. belladonna, used as anodyne, soporific, and hallucinogenic agents for that we practice the art and of a of of the Italy for his of reference In ancient the was a wine used as a from a and its was to one of a or of anesthesia, as used by such as to and … have been obtained from contemporaneous of other Greek is from as from anodyne, a derived from ancient Greek or to one of a the and Greek which also were used as with six of making a vertical bar] or of and the Greek - to of a of the or containing that may have been used as and ** ancient Greek to nine
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Robert S. Holzman (1998) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: