Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The writer's standpoint stated.-Criticism of the accepted d i f wencea between instinct and intelligence.-Rudiments of conation and meaning in imtincts.-Th.t? platicity of instincts.-Examination of ~J M dificulties of enumerating human imtincts.-Humanand anirnal intelligence.-Instinctand intelligence from the aspect of evolution.- Generd conclusion.INSTINCT and intelligence are generally regarded as two distinct modes of mental activity.I n the following paper I hope to give adequate reasons for abandoning this view.I shall endeavour to show that instinct and intelligence are everywhere inseparable, and that in every so-called instinctive or intelligent act, a concomitant aspect of intelligence or instinct may be obtained.I regard the separation of instinct and intelligence as a purely artificial act of abstractionconvenient, no doubt, for the purposes of psychological science, but resulting merely from regarding mental behaviour from two diflerent points of view.I conceive the relation of instinct and intelligence to be essentially similar to that of object to subject.S o far as instinctive behaviour can be regarded from the standpoint of the individual experience of the organism, it appears, however imperfectly, as " intelligent,"-characterised by finalism.So far as intelligent behaviour can be regarded from the standpoint of observing the conduct of other organisms, it appears, however imperfectly, as "instinctive,"-characterised by mechanism.Thus intelligence and instinct, choice and tropism, finalism and mechanism, are equally true and valid; they are our necessarily " anthropo-psychic " interpretations of one and the same problem regarded from different standpoints.This paper formed part of a symposium on the subject held at a joint meeting of the Aristotelian and British Psychological Societies and of the Mind Association in London in July, 1910.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Charles S. Myers (1910) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: