Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The purpose of this article is simple and straightforward. It is not, unfortunately, to offer new insights into why birds are coloured the way they are, much as I would like to know the answer to such a superficially simple question as why Common Blackbirds Turdus merula, Fieldfares Turdus pilaris and Song Thrushes Turdus philomelos, familiar species with so many ecological similarities, are so different in colour. Instead my aim is to remind readers that there are plumage features, for example white rumps and pale superciliary stripes, which occur with some regularity in a diverse array of unrelated species and for which there is no ready explanation. Given that I come from a mindset that expects plumage to have been shaped by natural selection, this failure to discern, in some cases, even the likely shape of an explanation is disconcerting. But I am certainly not the first to be frustrated by an inability to explain the variety of birds’ plumages (Butcher & Rohwer 1989, Marchetti & Price 1997). Bird plumage must provide the necessary surfaces for flight (excluding the minority of flightless species), and must fulfil a physiological role that is primarily insulating the homeothermic animal within. Occasionally, other physico-physiological functions can be discerned, such as dark marks on the lores (i.e. just in front of the eyes) of many tropical seabirds, which presumably reduce glare off the sea. Once these roles are fulfilled, and acknowledging that feathers of different colours may carry different metabolic costs and be variably durable, the plumage can contribute to camouflaging the bird from predators or prey and/or signalling to conspecifics or heterospecifics. Of course, because different feather tracts are visible in different circumstances, it is perfectly possible to combine camouflage and signalling (Wallace 1889). For example, the males of several nightjar species are cryptic at rest but, in flight, reveal white and highly visible wing and tail patches that probably play a role in territorial display and mate attraction (Holyoak 2001). This note is not concerned with sexually dimorphic features such as the black bibs of male House Sparrows Passer domesticus (Veiga 1993) or the red pectoral tufts and elongated tails of Scarlet-tufted Malachite Sunbirds Nectarinia johnstoni (Evans & Hatchwell 1992a,b) that are probably the result of either intra- or intersexual selection. Nor is it concerned with overall plumage brightness, also likely to be influenced by sexual selection (Hamilton & Zuk 1982). Rather, my intention is to highlight aspects of plumage shared by the sexes for which, a priori, an ecological explanation is more likely. Although it would be intellectually appealing if these plumage features were to have a common cause across all birds, this is unlikely to be the case. At the crudest level, some ecological generalities can be noted. Countershading, just one of the features that can contribute to camouflage (Cott 1940, Behrens 2009), is widespread among birds, as it is in the majority of vertebrates. Canopy-dwelling bird species, such as parrots and leaf warblers Phylloscopus spp., are commonly green, presumably because they live in a green light environment (Gomez & Théry 2004). Desert species are often sandy brown (Wallace 1889). Seabirds and wintering shorebirds, living entirely in the open, are variously black, grey, white or brown: none is predominantly red, green or blue. Socially foraging species tend to be white, and presumably more visible to conspecifics, than allied species which forage solitarily (Beauchamp & Heeb 2001). Once the broad ecological stage – and hence plumage – is set, it could be that the finer details of a species’ plumage are partly determined by a need to provide visible differentiation from congeners, as an aid to avoiding hybridization. McNaught and Owens (2002) tested this idea among a range of Australasian species, and found no support. But the idea may be worth further testing as the plumage features discussed below are found, and have probably evolved independently, in many bird taxa. Such independent evolution is to be expected if the feature plays a role in species recognition (Tobias & Seddon 2009). One widespread plumage feature is streaking of the upperparts and underparts. At first sight, a promising hypothesis is that this might contribute to crypsis in grassy habitats; think of larks (Alaudidae), pipits (Anthus spp.), Cisticola warblers and some accentors (Prunellidae), whose streaky plumage could camouflage the birds from predators. However, that hypothesis does not apply to streaked antbirds and antwrens (Thamnophilidae) living in the understory of South American forests, and still less to honeyeaters (Meliphagoidea) feeding in the crowns of Australian trees. It also signally fails to explain why parulid warblers of North America are conspicuously more streaked than their sylviid Palaearctic counterparts. An interesting test of the association of streakiness and habitat is potentially provided by groups that live in different habitats at different seasons. Calidrid waders, for example, are more streaked on the underparts in summer plumage when breeding in tundra habitat than in winter plumage when living on mudflats. Using new methods to assess crypsis (Stuart-Fox et al. 2004), it should be feasible to assess whether these seasonal changes do indeed render the bearers less visible. Streaking seems to be achieved in two main ways. The more frequent is a dark mark that parallels the feather shaft. When the marks on several feathers are aligned, a dark streak is apparent. But there are instances where the streaked effect arises from a pale central mark on an otherwise darker feather (e.g. woodcreepers Dendrocolaptinae, a minority of honeyeaters). Barring is less common than streaking. Its occurrence in owls and birds of prey (excluding both Old and New World Vultures) suggests an association with active predatory habits. Why barring should be advantageous to predators is not obvious, especially as some raptors are streaked when immature, only becoming barred when adult. Of especial interest in this context are the species of woodcreeper (in the genera Dendrocolaptes and Xiphocolaptes) and woodpecker (various genera) whose underparts are streaked in the throat/chest region and barred in the belly region. Given the behavioural similarities of the two groups, foraging vertically on tree trunks, an ecological cause is possible. Intriguingly, some other picids, namely certain piculets (Picumnus spp.), which often forage on more or less horizontal branches, are the only picids to be barred in the throat/chest region and streaked in the belly region. A distinctively coloured rump is a widespread feature of birds, with a white rump being the most common manifestation. In some groups, an explanation is available. For example, a white rump may be linked to flocking in waders (Brooke 1998) and it may aid geese to maintain station within an aerodynamically efficient flight formation (Lissaman & Schollenberger 1970). However, the sheer variety of birds with white rumps, including but not limited to storm-petrels (Hydrobatidae), eagles (various genera within the Accipitridae) and wheatears (Oenanthe spp.), suggests these explanations are not universally valid. Where a plumage feature has a signalling role, it would be expected that the feature could be displayed more or less conspicuously according to circumstances. This is not obviously the case with white rumps, which are necessarily displayed when the bird takes flight. Here, then, is a contrast to white undertail coverts, which can be made more or less visible according to the angle of the tail. Interspecific analysis of rails (Rallidae), many species of which possess these white coverts, suggests they contribute to anti-predator signalling (Stang & McRae 2009). Such contingent visibility is likely also to apply to another frequent plumage feature, white outer tail feathers that are potentially more or less visible according to how the tail is fanned (Fitzpatrick 1998), and commonly obscured in the folded tail by all-dark central tail feathers (Wallace 1889). Mumme (2002) reported that Slate-throated Redstarts Myioborus miniatus used their white outer tail feathers to flush insect prey. Randler (2006) noted that tail wagging by White Wagtails Motacilla alba, a behaviour presumably rendered more visible by the white outer tail feathers, appeared to be an honest signal of vigilance. However, it would be difficult to translate the particular results of these studies into predictions about which groups of birds are most likely to have white outer tail feathers. That said, my subjective impression is that the feature is most frequent in ground-dwelling birds, for example pipits and buntings, and less frequent in aerial species. This possible association could be tested. Given that white feathers are less durable than darker feathers containing melanin (McGraw 2006), the fact that the white seen in tails is so often confined to the tips, the outer feathers, or even the outer vane of the outermost feather, the very parts most liable to wear, suggests that the advantage(s) of the feature outweigh any costs resulting from increased wear. While several features hitherto mentioned might be associated with open habitats, Marchetti (1993) found that Phylloscopus warblers living in darker habits had brighter wing bars and more plumage patches. She suggested the patches were used in intra-specific communication. Whether the association with habitat extends to other groups remains to be thoroughly explored. Phylloscopus wingbars arise from pale tips to the coverts. However, wing bars, perhaps here better termed panels, can also occur when the proximal regions of the remiges are differently coloured than the tips. Such panels are revealed when the wing is extended but tend to be hidden when the bird’s wings are folded, a contrast to the wing bars created by covert tips, which are on permanent view. The final feature of birds I shall mention is a pale superciliary stripe. Studies of fish have suggested that a dark stripe through the eye may serve to disguise the position of the eye, a vulnerable part of the animal’s body (Barlow 1972). Perhaps that disguise is enhanced by a pale superciliary stripe above the eyestripe, the pattern in some birds. But it is uncertain whether this explanation also applies to the occurrence of a pale stripe above the eye in the absence of any dark stripe through the eye (e.g. in many shorebirds). The aim of this short discussion has been to point out a number of features which defy easy explanation, to suggest some tentative answers, and to prompt others to formulate detailed hypotheses amenable to either correlative investigation or experimental tests. Only then might we begin to acquire the ability to predict the likely plumage of species living in a certain habitat with a particular ecology. My thanks to Paul Donald, Martin Stevens, M.C. Stoddard and an anonymous referee for comments on this article.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
M. de L. Brooke (2010) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: