Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
To the Editor: We have some comments on a recently published article on the definition of epileptic seizures and epilepsy (1): As the authors say, those definitions are important for medical professionals. However, their article has just two references, which seem insufficient both to support their views and to allow others to assess the scientific basis of their assertions. The authors state that seizures can originate in the cerebral cortex, in thalamocortical interactive systems, or in the brainstem. As clinicians, we wonder which parts of the brainstem could be accepted as a source of seizures, and we would appreciate some relevant citations. We also would like to know whether seizures can arise in the cerebellum, as has been claimed (2-4). For us, it would be important to know the official position of the International League Against Epilepsy (ILAE) on these matters. We agree with the idea of sustaining the diagnosis of epilepsy after the first epileptic seizure, just as we consider that a patient has a cerebrovascular disease after his first stroke. What is difficult for us to interpret is the sentence “multiple epileptic seizures due to multiple different causes in the same patient would not be considered to be epilepsy.” In some examples in the literature, a patient is considered to have two types of epilepsy (5). Another sentence from the article deserves a comment: “a single epileptic seizure due to an enduring epileptic abnormality would indicate epilepsy, and a single epileptic seizure in a normal brain would not.” We can imagine an example: a teenager without any remarkable past event has a first generalized tonic–clonic seizure on awakening. In this case, we could suspect the presence of an idiopathic generalized epilepsy. However, if no family history of epilepsy exists and both the magnetic resonance image and the first electroencephalogram are normal, how could we demonstrate the “enduring epileptogenic abnormality”? If we could not, should we retain the ILAE term “unprovoked” isolated seizure to classify such cases and keep them apart from epilepsy and acute symptomatic seizures (6)? Stigma, exclusion, restrictions, overprotection, and isolation were all common in patients with tuberculosis some decades ago, but not now. In our opinion, these elements are not inherent to any disease and should not become part of the definition of tuberculosis or epilepsy. Finally, we do not understand why an official paper of the ILAE must be assessed by anonymous referees to be published in the official journal of the ILAE. What would have happened if they had advised not to publish the manuscript? The potential submission of the paper to another journal would appear strange indeed. Perhaps a better idea would be to present the important papers of the ILAE in preliminary form to an audience of epileptologists in some international meeting. This open discussion of the paper might have enriched it and might clarify its repercussions on the diagnosis and classification of epileptic seizures and syndromes.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Gómez-Alonso et al. (2005) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: