This is the authors' abstract. We don't add key points for this paper.
The growing divide in U.S. politics has significantly influenced how states administer their pension funds. Republican-controlled states have introduced laws prohibiting state pension funds from considering non-pecuniary factors. These states primarily cite concerns about potential breaches of fiduciary responsibility as their rationale. Conversely, Democratic-led states have taken the opposite approach, actively promoting or requiring the incorporation of Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) factors in pension investment decisions. This stark contrast reflects divergent perspectives on whether pension beneficiaries prioritize financial gains above all else or if they would accept potentially lower returns to support environmental and social objectives. This study empirically evaluates these assumptions with two large U.S. pension plan participant samples, using conjoint analysis—a cutting-edge method for preference measurement—to empirically assess assumptions about pension plan participants’ attitudes towards ESG features and their willingness to sacrifice profits to endorse environmental or social causes. This research is the first comprehensive U.S. effort to apply this method in the context of ESG investing with representative samples of the U.S. The findings show a clear partisan divide in attitudes regarding investment restrictions on firearms and fossil fuels. However, broad support exists for companies addressing child labor, living wages, and gender pay equality when these social goals are presented with specificity. In contrast, when social issues are framed more generally as “labor rights,” Republican participants tended to prioritize profitability. These results indicate that misconceptions about ESG and unawareness of social externalities may influence public support for anti-ESG legislation. They also reveal that neither ESG mandates nor bans may reflect the diverse preferences of pension beneficiaries. Properly addressing fiduciary concerns requires dissecting ESG into its components to match beneficiaries’ investments with their values more effectively.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Omar Vásquez Duque (2025) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: