Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
A postulate that low back pain cannot be diagnosed was published 50 years ago . This assumption was perpetuated for nearly 3 decades before more rigorous studies identified the sources of low back pain (LBP) . The medical community's initial impression that LBP cannot be determined is not correct. Published prevalence estimates with reasonable confidence intervals from three different continents have presented accurate accounts of different structural sources of LBP. The confidence intervals of these published prevalence estimates overlap. Indeed it is now factual that approximately 40%, 30%, and 20% of adults with chronic LBP are suffering from disc, facet joint, and sacroiliac joint related pain, respectively. These proportions change according to patient age with the prevalence of joint pain increasing and disc pain decreasing with advanced age . The medical community can now rest assured that under proper conditions, the source of chronic LBP can be identified. This certainty has far reaching implications. First, if specific spine structures are known to be a source of symptoms and disability, it is therefore reasonable and sensible to pursue their identification to prescribe target specific and definitive treatment. Such treatment must be cast in proper context-said treatment is warranted when LBP remains chronic, unremitting, and disabling. Second, after accepting that injury of spine structures can result in chronic LBP, utilization of diagnostic and therapeutic spine procedures should reflect the prevalence estimates for the structural sources of chronic LBP. Assessment of interventional spine procedure utilization patterns must incorporate the growing body of published evidence demonstrating prevalence rates for these sources of LBP. Spine care cost-containment measures cannot ignore these published findings. Third, practicing responsible interventional spine care will be enhanced by our improved ability to predict the source of the patient's LBP. Our clinical pathways for dispensing spine care will benefit by optimizing our capability to predict the most likely source of symptoms. For example, Verrills et al studied a large sample of LBP patients using sound, validated diagnostic procedures and calculated prevalence estimates for discogenic low back pain in two different age groups of patients: 22% (95%CI:17,26) in a group of patients with a mean age = 55 years, and 74% (95%CI:68,80) in a group of patients with a mean age = 43 years. The model proposed by DePalma et al. predicts a discogenic LBP prevalence of 35% (95%CI:25,45) for a 55 year old subject. This is in line with Verrills' findings as the lower bound of the 35% confidence interval overlaps the upper bound of the 22% confidence interval. Therefore, the two proportions are congruent. Verrills et al. utilized provocation lumbar discography (PLD) adhering to stringent operational criteria to assist in detecting the source LBP in their patients. Their study is an additional example of the proper use of diagnostic interventional spine procedures. PLD has acceptably low false positive rates . Verrills et al's findings corroborate previously reported low false positive rates and help solidify the role of PLD in diagnosing chronic LBP. In short, despite decades stating the contrary, it is entirely probable that the medical community can accurately diagnose the source of chronic LBP if the proper diagnostic measures are utilized. Logic holds that this is the first step in prescribing effective treatment. Treatment outcomes can only begin to succeed if the accuracy of the diagnosis is affirmed.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Michael J. DePalma (2015) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: