Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The Next Generation Science Standards (NGSS) emphasizes content and scientific practices, but what does this actually look like in a classroom? The NGSS integrates scientific and engineering practices with core ideas and crosscutting concepts, merging the three dimensions from A Framework for K-12 Science Education (NRC 2012). By engaging themselves in science, students understand how their knowledge develops, providing appreciation of the wide range of approaches that are used to investigate, model, and explain the world (NRC 2012, p. 42). The Framework identifies eight scientific and engineering practices (NRC 2012). This article focuses on the practice of modeling as a tool to engage students in additional scientific practices: arguing from evidence, communicating ideas, and developing understanding of core ideas. We discuss how to support students in model building by having them develop, share, and discuss atomic models and then revise those models based on observed electrostatic interactions. Scientific modeling In the NGSS, models include physical representations, conceptual relationships among elements of a system, and simulations. These models have explanatory and predictive power, and scientists use them to generate data, explore questions, solve problems, and communicate ideas. Models are consistent with evidence, demonstrating to students that if their models do not match new evidence, they should revise or replace them (Achieve 2013; Krajcik and Merritt 2012; Schwarz et al. 2009). Figure 1 details grade-band endpoints for the modeling practice (Achieve 2013, Appendix F, p. 6). To support students' engagement in scientific practices, teachers should create an environment full of rich phenomena and meaningful data from which students build initial models. Teachers then facilitate discussions by having students share their models and ask questions, such as * What similarities or differences exist between your models? * How do your models highlight different aspects of the phenomenon or data? * Can we, as a class, come to an agreement on what to include in our models? * Which models best account for the data? These questions require students to analyze and reflect and do not imply a right answer; the teacher asks probing questions and reflects students' ideas without judging responses. Model development To demonstrate how teachers can use modeling to support students' construction of knowledge and engagement in scientific practices, we use materials that support students in developing models of electrostatic interaction. These materials, under development as part of a National Science Foundation project (Michigan State University 2013; DRL #1232388), can explain a broad range of phenomena, forming connections among physics, chemistry, biology, and Earth science. Phase changes, chemical reactions, protein structure and function, and the energy in hurricanes all have a foundation in electrostatic forces, a concept that can help demonstrate to students the connected nature of science. In our curricula, students construct basic models of electrostatic forces and over time--through engagement with various phenomena, computer simulations, and peer discussion--develop their models into complex frameworks for understanding inter- and intramolecular forces. As students' models evolve, they have opportunities to illustrate the evolving nature of electrostatic interactions. Teachers can also use this formative feedback to guide classroom discussions. Figure 2 depicts some of the NGSS's performance expectations, core ideas, scientific practices, and crosscutting concepts (Achieve 2013) related to our curricula. Supporting argument from evidence and communication of ideas Students start by analyzing phenomena that involve interactions between charged objects. They note patterns in how charged objects interact with each other and how charged objects interact with neutral objects. …
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Mayer et al. (2013) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: