Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The nineteenth century saw a heated debate between those who saw music as pure, autonomous, and self-sufficient, and others who extolled music’s capacity to conjure images and narratives. The latter camp, known as the “programmaticists,” developed several concepts to justify their compositional strategies. Several scholars have drawn on programmaticist concepts to explore relationships between music and image in film, but there has been limited exploration of the applicability of programmaticism to game music. Using the role-playing game Hollow Knight (2017) as a case study, I propose that the aesthetic concepts of programmaticism can elucidate the audiovisual construction of meaning in game music. I first examine musical similarities and dissimilarities between game music and nineteenth-century program music. I interrogate issues of synchronicity, contending that the tightly framed discursive structures of programmatic art music often preclude it from aural similarity with game music. I explore metaphysical parallels between programmaticism and video game music in the second section. I contend that some examples of game music can be understood as a manifestation of an underlying Schopenhauerian Will. Further, I argue that the concept of the form motive, a “poetic idea” that is shared between music and extramusical content, can aid an understanding of the formation of meaning in game music. Based on an example from Hollow Knight, I propose to account for the unique characteristics of form motives in game music. I suggest a distinction between form motives and “ludic motives,” the latter category describing the congruence of musical material with ludic function. I introduce the term “protoludic” to describe how Jean Sibelius’s musical landscapes serve as a precedent for location-based music in video games. I argue that the manner in which the subjects of Sibelius’s landscapes are shown to be powerless transient agents is paralleled by the looping impassivity of locational music.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Max D. Rodney (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: