Key result
Body fat percentage identifies ~94% more obesity cases than BMI, suggesting BMI underestimates true adiposity.
Why the study?
Obesity is difficult to represent with a single method due to non-centralized adiposity, complicating assessment of obesity-related risks.
Do alternative methods of estimating adiposity provide a better assessment of obesity than BMI alone in Ghanaian women?
Cross-Sectional (n=467)
Do alternative methods of estimating adiposity provide a better assessment of obesity than BMI alone in Ghanaian women?
BMI may significantly underestimate true adiposity compared to body fat percentage, suggesting a multi-component model incorporating BAI, %BF, VF, and BMI may better represent obesity.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Prevalence estimates of obesity in Ghanaian women vary by adiposity measure; leaves open which best predicts cardiovascular outcomes.
Background Obesity is increasingly becoming a pandemic considering the many risks it pose to other disease conditions. Obesity is largely a measure of adiposity, however, adiposity is not centralized in the human body. This makes it difficult for any single method to adequately represent obesity and by extension the risks specific areas of adipose accumulation pose to specific disease conditions. Subjects/Methods We evaluated the prevalence of obesity in a cohort of Ghanaian women using the body mass index (BMI) and further sought to evaluate how it compares to other methods of estimating adiposity and the suitability of any particular methods representing obesity in general. We used anthropometry and bioimpedance derived measures of adiposity and derived other indices such as the abdominal volume index (AVI), body adiposity index (BAI) and conicity index (CI). Results Waist and hip circumference, body fat (%BF) and visceral fat (VF) were positively correlated to BMI whereas skeletal muscle mass was negatively correlated. Physical activity indices did not show any significant correlation with BMI. Prevalence of obesity was 16% and 31% using BMI and %BF respectively. Receiver operating characteristic analysis showed that whereas BMI is effective in predicting underweight, normal weight and obesity it was a poor predictor of overweight. Conclusions There was also no single measure that could adequately predict obesity as an accumulation fat. Hence, we developed and propose a model as a factor of BAI, %BF, VF and BMI. This model should correctly represent a person’s adiposity status and hence should be evaluated in large cohort studies.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Adedia et al. (2019) conducted a cross-sectional in Obesity (n=467). Body Mass Index (BMI) vs. Body Fat percentage (%BF) was evaluated on Prevalence of obesity. The prevalence of obesity in a cohort of Ghanaian women was 16% using body mass index compared to 31% using body fat percentage, suggesting BMI may underestimate true adiposity.
Synapse has enriched 8 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: