Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
DVB-RCS is really the first and only broadband satellite communications standard. With work started already in 1998 and the first version approved in the DVB project already in 1999—10 years ago—we are already talking of a mature technical specification. At the time the focus was on ATM to the desktop, Ka-band systems and large low-earth-orbit satellite constellations; or at least a lot of the community interest; and systems were proposed with several hundred satellites. In ETSI there were two alternative specifications published at the time for mobile satellite services based on GSM; these were the so-called GMR-1 and GMR-2 specification—both basically connected to one system each and one (or a few) vendors each. But, at the time there was also an increasing focus on standards. ETSI had just called for experts to the Broadband Satellite Multimedia Specialist Task Force—STF BSM, and as a result of this work established the BSM Work Group. ETSI was also the focus for the regulatory-oriented telecommunications specifications—the so-called ‘harmonized standards’ that describe a way—in practice the only practical way—satellite terminals (or other telecommunications terminals) could comply with the new RTT&E Directive. This directive basically removed any requirements for standards but stated that different systems should be able to co-exist through regulating the unwanted emissions of radio signals; thus, the amount of noise one could allow into other bands or orbital locations. Article 3.2 of the RTT&E directive also had a clause stating that while standards were not mandatory, stated that the communications interface should be published. While some argued that this meant the input and output interfaces—could both be IP for instance—others believed that it was the air interface such as the GSM system that was making world-wide success at the time (and still is). Whatever one might have believed—the fact remains that DVB-RCS is just such an interface and it is published. At that time, a decade or so ago, there was also a major interest in the 2.5 GHz of Ka-band spectrum that was being made available for satellites. While not all of it would be for user terminals, some was reserved, for example, up- and downlink from gateways, it was still considered attractive enough to trigger a fairly significant auction with the FCC in the U.S. Satellite communications spectrum and orbital locations were attractive assets. All of the 13 or so U.S. proposals offered broadband services, yet none at the time focused on Internet applications or Internet access. In retrospect this is quite interesting. Further, it was all very U.S. driven. Europe needed to ‘do something’, and perhaps inspired by the success of GSM, that came out of the European collaborative approach, an initiative was made by the European Space Agency (ESA) to create the first broadband satellite standard. At the time ETSI was a fairly new organization and the DVB project had some 5 years before it already published the excellent DVB-S specifications—through ETSI. As DVB-S was a forward link only, a return link over satellite was needed and DVB-RCS activities were initiated, and further completed as DVB-RCS EN 301 790, ‘Digital Video Broadcasting (DVB); Interaction channel for satellite distribution systems’. Since then several revisions have been done. The mobile version is the fifth one making it in ETSI notation EN 301 790 version 1.5.1. We named it DVB-RCS+M in the ‘DVB Group’ to indicate that the ‘+M’ is a mobile extension to DVB-RCS. To date, this version was probably the most significant update to the specification. We called it a revitalization of the open standard for satellite communications—and at least so far the momentum around DVB-RCS has increased substantially. There are several substantial new technologies in DVB-RCS+M that are both useful and required for mobile applications while also forming a path, it seems, to a future evolution to the next-generation work that is taking place now. The experts that have been proposing and working with them describe all the main technologies in this journal of invited articles. Dr Paul Thompson at the University of Surrey, who has been a prime motivator for establishing the DVB-RCS Mobile standard, along with the guest editor for this issue and TM-RCS Working Group chairman, Dr Harald Skinnemoen, gives an overview of the DVB-RCS+M development. It helps to frame the work that took place and allows readers hopefully to better understand the background and motivation for the work done on RCS+M. We also emphasize the need for an approved commercial basis for all the technical work in DVB through highlighting the specific commercial requirements for DVB-RCS+M. The use of DVB-S and DVB-RCS for conducting two-way communications from small satellite terminals has become well established in Europe and elsewhere. During the development of DVB-RCS the possibility of limited use for satellite terminals that were ‘on the move’ was considered in January 2004 and incorporated into the Guideline document associated with the Standard in April 2005. It was noted, however, that this matter be addressed further as a future development. Technical analysis identified that DVB-RCS, as it had been originally designed for fixed satellite services, provided most of the features required by mobile applications above 5 GHz, and could be turned into a competitive solution with a few carefully crafted modifications. Subsequent activities within the DVB TM-RCS Group have led to an efficient and robust standard that incorporates mobility more specifically into version 1.5.1 of the DVB-RCS specifications, along with appropriate detailed ‘Guidelines’ documentation giving expanded description of the standard and its use and application. The ESA has contributed substantially to the technical and business development work. Several of the key technologies partly or fully have their origin in projects that have been supported by ESA. Ana Bolea Alamanac et al. present a article titled ‘DVB-RCS goes mobile: challenges and technical solutions’. This article presents an overview of the DVB-RCS system addressing mobile scenarios (DVB-RCS+M). It analyses the challenges linked to the mobility support and it summarizes some of the techniques to cope with those challenges. The focus of this article is on the technical solutions analyzed within the framework of ESA studies and contracts. In particular, this article addresses in detail the proactive retransmission technique and the seamless handover mechanisms including beam, satellite, gateway and gap-filler handovers. Pansoo Kim et al. present an article titled ‘Direct Sequence Spectrum Spreading Techniques for Next Generation Mobile Broadband Satellite Services’. DVB-RCS+M supports direct sequence spectrum spreading (DS-SS) in the forward link. The spreading mode on top of the conventional structure of the fixed DVB-S2, allows an efficient extension of DVB-S2 to mobile terminals with small antennas operating in Ku/Ka frequency bands. Spectrum spreading is basically introduced to augment the received energy without increasing the transmitted power density, constrained due to regulatory aspect, and further to enhance resilience to co-channel interference. In this article the authors report on the design and assessment of the DS-SS technique carried out for DVB-RCS+M. In particular, by comparing the physical layer performance of the spread and non-spread modes in the specific DVB-RCS+M mobile scenarios, they show that the proposed DS-SS technique has no impact on the DVB-RCS+M data detection performance, while satisfying the requirements on interference resilience and received energy augmentation. In order to deal with the acquisition issues raised by the introduction of the DS-SS technique, they then propose and evaluate several synchronization concepts able to deal with the specific impairments of the mobile satellite scenarios, that is, large frequency offsets, phase noise, link obstructions, etc. Even a possible implementation of the DS-SS technique that fully accommodates the reuse of the specific hardware compatible with conventional DVB-S2 is also reported. In mobile environments it is quite possible that a communication link may be broken for a short while. Therefore, DVB-RCS+M has a unique solution for this. Jiang Lei, et al. present an article titled ‘Link Layer FEC for Quality-of-Service provision for Mobile Internet Services over DVB-S2’. This article presents the performance that can be achieved when applying forward error correction (FEC) at the link layer (LL) level for DVB-S2-based transmission to attain reliable reception in mobile environments. Their scenario of focus is the interactive railway scenario with two different channel assumptions: line-of-sight together with the effect of railway power archers (LOS+PA) and non-line of sight (nLOS). The authors analyze the performance and compatibility of the different LL-FEC schemes already available in the DVB family of standards: Multiple Protocol Encapsulation-FEC (MPE-FEC) and MPE Inter-Burst FEC (MPE-IFEC). They then compare their performance when adopting Reed-Solomon (RS) or Raptor FEC Codes. Both theoretical and simulation analysis reveals that LL-FEC can overcome the fade in the railway scenario by selecting appropriate FEC codes. The specific solution that was adopted in the DVB-RCS+M standard is discussed and two cross-layer transmission architectures are presented that allow adaptive quality of service provision over generic LL encapsulation. In a mobile environment as mainly considered for DVB-RCS+M, it is actually the user group including the mobile that moves, such as a bus, train, ship, plane, etc. This suggests that, in contrast to, for example, home- and single user DVB-RCS terminals as well as in contrast to mobile phones, there is, in fact, a group of users behind the terminal. Mobile RCS terminals are usually not expected to be for single users. In this case a great deal of traffic shaping can be done at the IP layer and when the traffic enters the terminal, this can result in a more continuous demand for capacity over the satellite link and less need for the demand assignment multiple access (DAMA) protocol in the current fixed DVB-RCS. There is an estimated 30% gain in efficiency by using a continuous carrier approach in this case, and DVB-RCS+M supports the use of DVB-S2 also in the return link. However, DVB-S2 was made for high data rates as in the forward link and a simple scaling down leads to very long delay for the link due to the coding time frames. An efficient approach to coding for low delay and low rate DVB-S2 was needed. Gianluigi Liva et al. present the article ‘The Very Short Frame of Mobile DVB-RCS: Code Design and QoS Performance’. In this article, the design of a new very short frame introduced in the DVB-RCS+M, standard targeting interactive mobile services, is described. The frame design, with a special focus on channel coding design and performance, is addressed in detail. The authors also present an evaluation of the QoS performance for realistic traffic scenarios, propagation channel conditions and carrier sizes. DVB-RCS+M is a substantial update for DVB-RCS and we see several of the technologies that were successfully introduced as potential candidates also for the next-generation DVB-RCS that at the time of writing. But even on its own the mobile version of RCS is a powerful solution, quite unique in the world. I am happy to see the large interest and commitment from the many players in the field. DVB-RCS meetings are attended by an increasing number of parties and I know there are many more just working in the background as partners or sub-contractors on various projects. There is interest from Asia as well as, of course, Europe and America. For those of us who believe that the satellite community is too small to fragment into various solutions but large enough to benefit from global standards, such as basically any other modern telecommunications technology, it is a delight to see the recent progress and support. I hope these excellent articles can serve both to demonstrate the high technological level of DVB-RCS, the firm orientation to practical and commercial needs and the potential for the technology. Furthermore, it is hoped that they serve as an inspiration, for all not yet involved, to contribute to the future of satellite communications as part of a community.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Harald Skinnemoen (2010) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: