Key result
Adding breathing and mindfulness to yoga shows no benefit over yoga alone for cardiac activity.
Why the study?
Yoga exercise can positively affect well-being and cardiac autonomic activity, but immediate effects of a single session with or without breathing and mindfulness instructions on emotion processing and heart rate variability are unclear.
Does a single session of yoga exercise with controlled breathing and mindful body awareness instructions improve heart rate variability and emotion processing compared to yoga without these instructions in young healthy women?
RCT (n=30)
Randomly assigned
Does a single session of yoga exercise with controlled breathing and mindful body awareness instructions improve heart rate variability and emotion processing compared to yoga without these instructions in young healthy women?
A single session of yoga exercise improves affective judgments and bodily awareness in healthy young women, but adding explicit breathing and mindfulness instructions does not provide additional benefits to cardiac autonomic activity.
Does not support adding breathing/mindfulness instructions for cardiac benefits in healthy women; confirms acute affective gains from yoga movement alone.
Exercise is indispensable for a healthy lifestyle. Yoga exercise can have positive effects on well-being and on cardiac autonomic activity making it an ideal intervention for improving mind-body interactions and resilience to physical and mental stressors. Emotions trigger especially strong bodily and affective-cognitive responses because of their social relevance for the self and their biological relevance of mobilizing the organism for action. This study investigates whether changes in emotion processing related to self-other referential processing and changes in cardiac autonomic activity, reflected by heart rate variability (HRV), occur immediately after already a single session of yoga exercise when yoga postures are practiced with or without breathing- and mindful body awareness instructions. Women, all university students (N = 34, final sample: n = 30, n = 25 naïve to yoga practice) were randomly assigned to two experimental groups who performed the same yoga exercises with or without controlled breathing and mindfulness instructions. Emotional, self-other referential processing, awareness of bodily signals and HRV indicators were investigated before and after the exercise using standardized experimental tasks, standardized questionnaires, and mobile recording devices. Exercising for 30 minutes changed cardiac activity significantly. HRV measures showed adaptability of cardiac activity during the exercise as well as during the affective task post- to pre-exercise. Exercising with breathing instructions and mindful body awareness had no superior effects on cardiac, particularly parasympathetic activity, compared to practicing the same movements without such explicit instructions. Self-referential processing did not change; however, participants were faster and more accurate in their affective judgments of emotional stimuli [regardless of their reference (self/other)], and showed better awareness of bodily signals after compared to before the exercise session. The results support immediate, adaptive effects of yoga exercise on cardiac and affective-cognitive processing in an all-female healthy sample. Therefore, yoga exercise could be recommended as a physical activity for boosting cardiac and emotional resilience in this target group.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Cornelia Herbert (2021) conducted an RCT in Healthy (n=30). Yoga exercise with controlled breathing and mindful body awareness instructions vs. Yoga exercise without controlled breathing and mindfulness instructions was evaluated on Changes in emotion processing and cardiac autonomic activity (HRV). A single 30-minute yoga session improved affective judgments and bodily awareness in healthy women, but adding breathing and mindfulness instructions had no superior effect on cardiac activity.
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: