Key result
Global Mood Scale proves more responsive than SF-36 to health status changes in cardiopulmonary rehabilitation.
Why the study?
Patient outcome measures are essential to map treatment effectiveness in cardiac and pulmonary rehabilitation, but no gold standard POM has been established and responsiveness varies across instruments.
Which patient outcome measures are most responsive to change in health status pre- to post-cardiac and pulmonary rehabilitation?
Systematic Review
Which patient outcome measures are most responsive to change in health status pre- to post-cardiac and pulmonary rehabilitation?
In cardiac and pulmonary rehabilitation, disease-specific POMs, Likert scales, and simple questionnaires are more responsive to changes in health status than generic or complex instruments like the SF-36.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Select Global Mood Scale over SF-36 to detect rehabilitation gains; confirms disease-specific and simple measures outperform generic instruments.
BACKGROUND: Cardiac and pulmonary rehabilitation have been shown to reduce the symptoms of disease, as well as reducing health care utilization. To ensure the continuation of these programs, patient outcome measures (POMs) are essential to map treatment effectiveness. This review is a comparative effectiveness literature review of studies with a pre- to post-POM assessment of responsiveness (ie, change in health status over time). METHODS: A quality review of the literature included not only randomized controlled trials but also parallel studies, as well as all observational and retrospective trials. This review included a list of articles and their characteristics; a quality assessment of the literature and a list of POMs utilized in this setting were assessed for responsiveness. RESULTS: There was inconsistency in the literature with the measurement of responsiveness or effect size. The most commonly used POM was the SF-36; however, it was found to be less responsive to change in health status pre- to post-rehabilitation, particularly in the mental domain of this instrument. The most responsive POM in this setting was the Global Mood Scale. CONCLUSION: The surveyed literature found no "gold standard" POM for either cardiac rehabilitation or pulmonary rehabilitation but there was some preference for the disease-specific POMs; however, some of these instruments lose their discriminatory power at the end of the rehabilitation period. This literature review found that a Likert scale is more responsive than a dichotomous scale and that a simple questionnaire is more responsive in a pre- to post-setting than a complex questionnaire.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Rotterdam et al. (2019) conducted a systematic review in Cardiac and pulmonary rehabilitation. Patient outcome measures (POMs) was evaluated on Responsiveness (change in health status over time). The Global Mood Scale was the most responsive patient outcome measure in cardiac and pulmonary rehabilitation, whereas the commonly used SF-36 was less responsive to changes in health status.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: