Key result
Russian AUDIT lacks rigorous primary care validation and suffers from 61 significantly inconsistent translations.
Why the study?
Little is known about the empirical basis and validation of the AUDIT in Russia despite its widespread use and multiple translations with inconsistencies.
Systematic Review (n=134)
There is a critical need for a rigorous validation study of the Russian AUDIT due to the absence of prior large-scale validation and the existence of numerous inconsistent translations.
Urges caution with inconsistent AUDIT translations in Russian primary care; leaves open the need for large-scale validation studies.
The Alcohol Use Disorders Identification Test (AUDIT) is one of the most frequently used screening instrument for hazardous and harmful use of alcohol and potential alcohol dependence in primary health care (PHC) and other settings worldwide. It has been translated into many languages and adapted and modified for use in some countries, following formal adaptation procedures and validation studies. In the Russian Federation, the AUDIT has been used in different settings and by different health professionals, including addiction specialists (narcologists). In 2017, it was included as a screening instrument in the national guidelines of routine preventive health checks at the population-level (dispanserization). However, various Russian translations of the AUDIT are known to be in use in different settings and, so far, little is known about the empirical basis and validation of the instrument in Russia—a country, which is known for its distinct drinking patterns and their detrimental impact on health. The present contribution is the summary of two systematic reviews that were carried out to inform a planned national validation study of the AUDIT in Russia.Two systematic searches were carried out to 1) identify all validation efforts of the AUDIT in Russia and to document all reported problems encountered, and 2) identify all globally existing Russian translations of the AUDIT and document their differences and any reported issues in their application. The qualitative narrative synthesis of all studies that met the inclusion criteria of the first search highlighted the absence of any large-scale rigorous validation study of the AUDIT in primary health care in Russia, while a document analysis of all of the 122 Russian translations has revealed 61 unique versions, most of which contained inconsistencies and signaled obvious application challenges of the test.The results clearly signal the need for a validation study of the Russian AUDIT.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Neufeld et al. (2021) conducted a systematic review in Alcohol use disorders (n=134). Alcohol Use Disorders Identification Test (AUDIT) in Russian was evaluated on Validation efforts and translation inconsistencies of the Russian AUDIT. The systematic review revealed an absence of large-scale rigorous validation studies of the AUDIT in Russian primary health care and identified 61 unique translations with significant inconsistencies.
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: