This is the authors' abstract. We don't add key points for this paper.
To the Editor: We read with great interest the recently published 2024 National Resident Matching Program Charting Outcomes and the work by Coyle et al on recommendation letters.1,2 The great bottleneck in the journey of becoming a neurosurgeon is The Match due to a limited number of residency spots. Recently, there have been two major events that have changed the landscape of the residency application process. The 2020 Match Week began on March 16, 2020, exactly one day after the United States (US) began to implement shutdowns to limit the transmission of COVID-19. Although the pandemic did not necessarily affect the 2020 match, its effects are obvious in the differences between the National Resident Matching Program Charting Outcomes data from 2020 to 2022. Our letter focuses on US graduates of allopathic medicine (MD) programs because these sample sizes are the largest. The biennial Charting Outcomes data for US MDs are available from 2016 to 2024.2-6 The difference in the average number of ranks between those who matched and those who did not was 5.5 (15.7 vs 10.2) in 2016, 7.9 (16.4 vs 8.5) in 2018, 5.9 (15.8 vs 10.0) in 2020, and a surprising 11.7 (18.7 vs 7.0) in 2022.3-6 The difference decreased to 7.6 (16.9 vs 9.1) in 2024 (Figure 1).2 The observed difference in 2022 is conceivably because of the advent of virtual residency interviews. Applicants were no longer required to spend time and money on travel and could therefore attend more interviews. As an unanticipated result, the strongest applicants (on paper) were able to collect a large share of the limited, available interviews. As programs have returned to in-person interviews (approximately 60% this last application cycle per medical students that rotated with us), the difference in number of programs ranked was less dramatic.FIGURE 1.: Line graph depicting difference between the average number of programs ranked of matched and unmatched neurosurgical residency applicants.In addition, in 2021, the United States Medical Licensing Examination announced that Step 1 would transition to pass/fail in January 2022. As Step 1 is traditionally taken in the second year of medical school, the first class of applicants who primarily took a pass/fail version of Step 1 applied to residency this past 2023-2024 cycle. While we expected to see an increase in Step 2 scores, there was not a drastic increase. The average Step 2 score for a matched neurosurgery applicant in 2016 was 251 compared with 255 in 2024 (Figure 2). However, it could be argued that an increase was not observed because the examination scores are normalized.FIGURE 2.: Line graph depicting the average Step 2 scores of neurosurgical residency applicants stratified by matched and unmatched status.It seems that the energy toward standing out is being spent on research productivity. The average number of research products including abstracts, presentations, and papers for a matched applicant increased from 25.5 in 2022 to 37.4 in 2024.2,6 Even for unmatched US MD applicants, there was a near three-fold increase from 11.7 in 2022 to 31.8 in 2024 (Figure 3). Indeed, it seems that the gap between the matched and unmatched applicants is closing. Despite this, the match rate for US MDs applying to neurosurgery was below 70% in 2024 for the first time, although US MDs still make up >84% of matched neurosurgery applicants.FIGURE 3.: Line graph depicting the average number of research products (abstracts, presentations, publications, etc.) of neurosurgical residency applicants stratified by matched and unmatched status.With less differentiating data points and a figurative applicant arms race, the question becomes how do we as a profession ensure the best applicants are selected? Subinternships (also known as acting internships) are a time-tested method that certainly provides valuable insight, and applicants are expected to obtain recommendation letters. However, even recommendation letters are imperfect, with Feldman et al noting that 90% rated applicants in the top quartile and Coyle et al noting some degree of implicit bias.1,7 The residency match algorithm is designed to create optimal matches, but it is individually up to programs and applicants to determine what they consider to be a good match. Signaling, which was introduced in the 2022 to 2023 application cycle, has affected the process to an extent and can influence programs to be more interested in an applicant. But how do we go beyond this? How do we avoid underperformance, burnout, and attrition? How do we quantify the buzz words of “resilience?” We are certain that all fields in medicine seek an optimal method for identifying who will be successful in their field, and a solution would be priceless. It is unclear what will affect next the application process as significantly as COVID-19 or the transition of Step 1 to a pass/fail examination did, but we must certainly remain vigilant and work toward a solution that strengthens our field by selecting the best while allowing for underrepresented groups to gain representation, diversifying the field. Perhaps the best solution is to simply optimize the “match” between a program and applicant, which may be catalyzed by signaling, as observed by our orthopedic surgery colleagues.8 From there, perhaps it is up to the programs to then foster resilience. Further research into the optimization of the neurosurgery residency application process is needed. It would be worthwhile to evaluate patterns of applicant signaling and possibly even evaluate attrition based on whether applicants matched at programs they signaled vs programs that rotated at. As our field is among the smallest in medicine, each neurosurgeon or trainee can have a bigger impact.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Nguyen et al. (2025) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: