Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The review article in this issue of the Indian Journal of Ophthalmology (IJO) focuses on eye banking practices in India, the European nations, and the United States of America.[1] Around 5.5 million people are bilaterally blind worldwide due to corneal diseases. Many more are being added to this number daily, but the majority do not have access to a donor cornea.[2] The reasons for this are manifold. Lack of infrastructure, awareness, and finance and absence of trained personnel are some of the reasons. When 53% of the world population does not have access to a donor cornea, something is seriously amiss.[3] It is more than a century since the first cornea transplant was conducted by Zirm. The procurement and distribution of donor corneas remains skewed. On one hand, established eye banks can distribute high-quality precut, preloaded, and stamped tissues for Descemet’s stripping automated endothelial keratoplasty (DSAEK) and Descemet’s membrane endothelial keratoplasty (DMEK) and even bioengineered tissue, and on the other hand, whole globe and moist chamber preservation techniques are practiced in smaller eye banks with minimum infrastructure and facilities.[4] What then is the need of the hour? How can this wide chasm be bridged? Eye banks worldwide are not governed by a uniform code of conduct or any laws. In India, the Eye Bank Association of India (EBAI) is a not-for-profit society formed in 1989 to promote the cause of eye banking.[1] Every nation’s government has its policies regarding organ transplantations. In India, the National Organ and Tissue Transplant Organization (NOTTO) coordinates procurement and distribution of organs and tissues. All eye banks need to send their data of collection and utilization to this organization. The Transplantation of Human Organs and Tissue Act (THOTA), 1994 was introduced by the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare and enacted by the Indian Parliament. It deals with the donation and transplantation of 11 organs and tissues from a live or deceased donor. In 2011, as a modification of this act, the human cornea was classified as tissue, and trained technicians were allowed to harvest donor corneas.[1,5] Collection data of eye banks across India shows better rates of eye donation in the western and southern parts of India.[6] Geographic variations exist due to differences in religious and cultural beliefs as well as general awareness of the population regarding organ donation. Similarly, the prevalence of corneal blindness and its causative factor varies in different parts of India. Less than half of the eye banks in India are functional and collect >100 donor corneas in a year.[1] This review article has focused on eye banking practices in the USA, Europe, and Asia.[1] The standard operating procedures and functioning have been highlighted. The role of supporting organizations such as Sight Life has also been discussed. The role of hospital corneal retrieval program (HCRP) versus voluntary eye donation (VED) in increasing the number of eye donations shows that HCRP is far more successful at present. What is the way forward then? As of now, in India, filling out a pledge form for eye donation while alive does not ensure that the next of kin is legally bound to donate the eye of the deceased. There is a severe lack of awareness regarding organ donation in populations across the globe, except perhaps in countries like Sri Lanka and the USA.[1] Would legislation make it mandatory for the next of kin to honor the pledge for eye donation made by the deceased in their lifetime? Further, strengthening the hospital-based retrieval programs and increasing voluntary eye donations by conducting awareness programs via mass media, social media, and governmental and non-governmental organizations right from the grassroots levels may help. Collaboration between different eye banks in a country and globally to balance demand and supply in different regions is needed. There are many hurdles to inter-eye bank transfer of tissues locally and globally. Legal hurdles, transport, costs, the perishable nature of the biological products, and religious and cultural differences make this difficult. Bioengineering of corneal tissue will address the aspect of long-term survival of the tissues. Till this happens, availability of intermediate and long-term preservative media, training of corneal surgeons, technical training provided to paramedical staff to retrieve corneoscleral rims and whole globes, and use of one tissue for more than one patient (Descemet’s membrane for DMEK and stroma for deep anterior lamellar keratoplasty [DALK]): all need to be done on a global scale. Well-equipped eye banks attached to apex eye hospitals the world over have to take the lead in an altruistic manner by training corneal surgeons, technicians, and grief counselors and by providing storage media and efficient transport of tissue to underserved areas of the world. Public awareness regarding eye donation can be effective by involving public figures to propagate the cause. Eye banks have to be truly “not-for-profit” organizations. Research and development have to also be at the forefront to develop alternatives to human tissue to address the shortage of donor corneas.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Sridhar et al. (2023) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: