Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
To the Editor, Smokeless tobacco (SLT) is any form of tobacco product taken by chewing or keeping it in the mouth. As this product enters the body through the gastrointestinal tract or by the sublingual route, the addictiveness of SLT is much higher than that of smoked tobacco. SLT consumption is particularly prevalent among adult populations in Bangladesh, Myanmar, Pakistan, India, Nepal, Bhutan, and Sri Lanka. Of concern is the fact that Bangladesh is ranked second among 34 countries with a high burden of SLT usage, with 20.6% of adults in the country regularly using SLT in different forms.[1] The percentage is considerably higher in women (24.8%) than men (16.2%). Of those who use SLT, 71.8% specifically use betel leaf with zarda or a zarda-supari combination. About 28.0% use betel leaf with sada pata, 3.6% use pan masala with tobacco, 2.3% exclusively chew sada pata, and 9% use other SLT products. SLT intake is more prevalent among females, middle-aged or older individuals, and those with lower levels of education, lower occupational status, and lower economic situations.[2,3] As per the reports from 2010 in Bangladesh, approximately 320,000 disability-adjusted life years (DALYs) were lost due to the high incidence of oral cancer, stroke, and heart diseases, all of which are associated with the use of SLT. In the rural areas of Bangladesh, the use of SLT is linked to several health issues, such as high blood pressure, obesity, cardiovascular disease, oral cancer, stroke, and hypertension, leading to higher mortality and morbidity rates. The use of SLT is influenced by the factors such as age, gender, level of education, and socioeconomic position. It is more widespread in rural areas than in urban areas, and the demand for SLT products is affected by factors such as seasonality, time of month, and festivals. In 2013, the Tobacco Control Law was enacted in Bangladesh, which reported that graphic health warnings covering 50% of the surface area be included on SLT packaging. The law also banned the advertising of SLT products and placed restrictions on their sale to nonadults (minors). However, the enforcement of this legislation is weak. To reduce the use of SLT, it is important to implement culturally sensitive public awareness campaigns and to improve tax and cessation services.[1] A research study found that 25% of people who use SLT products started using them because they were influenced by their family members. They were primarily attracted by the flavor and chewing habits of their family members. Other factors include influence from relatives, neighbors, grandparents, parents-in-law, teachers, and relief from toothache. Five percent of users turned to SLT to help reduce their addiction after quitting smoking. Three percent started using SLT during cultural events, while 2% used it to alleviate pregnancy-related difficulties. Some female participants sought advice from older relatives, and a smaller proportion mentioned getting advice from their mothers. Fifty-two percent of individuals in Bangladesh use SLT products due to addiction, and 23% consider it to be a habitual part of their lifestyle. SLT consumers are more likely to attribute their usage to family tradition, relief from toothache, enhanced flavor, anxiety relief, and overall taste improvement. However, individuals are less likely to acknowledge their use of these substances due to addiction or a lack of awareness about the potential harmful consequences. The results highlight the importance of understanding the perspectives of SLT consumers in Bangladesh.[4] A study group conducted semi-structured interviews with 20 stakeholders from government, nongovernment entities, and foreign funding institutions. The results revealed a lack of a nationwide policy on disclosing dangerous substances, illegal trading, and using standardized packaging for SLT products. The legislation regarding graphical health warnings and tax measures has been ineffective. Challenges to controlling SLT use included insufficient law enforcement, limited research, poor monitoring, inadequate evidence production, and ineffective supply chain management. The report also identified discrepancies between SLT policies and the Framework Convention on Tobacco Control (FCTC) due to slow implementation, lack of tailored national policies, and interference from the industry. The participants suggested that adhering to the FCTC requires effective leadership, political dedication, collaboration between public and commercial sectors, and efficient use of tobacco control resources.[5] The data from the Global Adult Tobacco Survey between 2009 and 2017 show that SLT usage in Bangladesh has decreased from 27.2% to 20.6%. However, in 2017, the use of SLT led to a minimum of 16,947 deaths and 403,460 DALYs lost. The policy priorities for controlling the consumption of SLT include implementing targeted taxation, raising the health development surcharge, establishing a tax monitoring system, standardizing the packaging of SLT products, incorporating SLT cessation programs into existing healthcare systems, conducting comprehensive media campaigns, and regulating the licensing of SLT manufacturers. Nevertheless, there are still deficiencies in the implementation and adherence to SLT control regulations in Bangladesh, suggesting that the burden of SLT-related diseases continues to increase, despite the decrease in SLT use and the typical delay between tobacco exposure and the development of cancer. Enhancing SLT management may expedite this decreasing trend and diminish SLT-related illness and death.[6] Ahmed[7] analyzed the existing taxation framework on SLT items in Bangladesh. The study also assessed the internal and cross-price elasticities of demand for these products. The government’s complex and multi-layered ad valorem SLT structure poses challenges, as the tax base determined by the tariff value is lower than the actual retail price. Reduced SLT costs promote the substitution of SLT with other less harmful alternatives while discouraging the abandonment of SLT altogether. Rural families are more sensitive to price fluctuations compared to urban households; while impoverished households show greater sensitivity to price changes than affluent households. The results indicate that raising the pricing of SLT would significantly decrease SLT use while also generating more income for the government.[7] In a nutshell, factors affecting SLT consumption are quite different from those affecting smoked tobacco. In Bangladesh, SLT use is sometimes considered a matter of pride and part of the culture. In addition, many SLT products are unbranded and locally made. Therefore, the controlling measures for SLT should be different from those of smoked tobacco (i.e.-cigarettes). The government and nongovernment organizations should craft and implement customized controlling policies for SLT. Financial support and sponsorship Nil. Conflicts of interest There are no conflicts of interest.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Mitra et al. (2024) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: