Key result
Cardiologists order ~106% more treadmill tests than internists for uncomplicated syncope.
Why the study?
Whether cardiologists or internists use discretionary tests differently for noncritical cardiological presentations was unclear.
Does clinical decision making and test ordering differ between cardiologists and internists for noncritical cardiological presentations?
Cross-Sectional (n=916)
Does clinical decision making and test ordering differ between cardiologists and internists for noncritical cardiological presentations?
Cardiologists and internists differ substantially in discretionary test use for noncritical cardiology scenarios, with cardiologists focusing more on cardiological tests and internists on broader evaluations, though overall charges are similar.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Specialty differences in discretionary testing warrant caution in noncritical scenarios; leaves open whether cardiologist-led patterns improve outcomes or increase overutilization.
BACKGROUND: Whether cardiologists or internists use discretionary tests differently for noncritical cardiological presentation is unclear. OBJECTIVE: To explore differences in decision making for 3 common scenarios. METHODS: We asked 318 cardiologists and 598 internists to manage scenario patients presenting with (1) uncomplicated syncope, (2) nonanginal chest pain, and (3) nonspecific electrocardiographic changes. Participants also estimated baseline clinical risk for each scenario and answered questions on uncertainty, malpractice concerns, and cost consciousness. We used chi 2 analysis, analysis of variance, and t tests to compare management choice and test ordering. Response rate was 50%. RESULTS: Initial management choices (ie, admit or discharge, allow or delay surgery) were similar but subsequent testing differed substantially. For a 50-year-old woman with uncomplicated syncope, cardiologists more often recommended cardiological tests such as exercise treadmill tests (37% vs 18%, 95% confidence interval [CI] for difference: 10%-28%) and signal-averaged electrocardiograms (13% vs 4%, 95% CI for difference: 3%-15%) but less often requested neurological tests (29% vs 37%, 95% CI for difference: -17% to 1%). For a 42-year-old man with nonanginal chest pain, cardiologists more frequently ordered exercise tests (70% vs 51%, 95% CI for difference: 10%-28%). For a 53-year-old woman with nonspecific electrocardiographic changes, equal proportions of cardiologists and internists ordered exercise tests (56%) but cardiologists recommended thallium studies more often (73% vs 47%, 95% CI for difference: 10%-36%). For all scenarios, average charges for diagnostic evaluations by cardiologists and internists were similar. CONCLUSIONS: In 3 noncritical cardiology scenarios, discretionary test use by cardiologists and internists differed substantially, although this was not reflected in dollar resources. Internists tended toward a broader diagnostic evaluation while cardiologists tended to focus on cardiological tests. The potential effect on clinical outcomes is unknown.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Peter Glassman (1997) conducted a cross-sectional in Noncritical cardiological presentations (n=916). Cardiologist specialty vs. Internist specialty was evaluated on Recommendation of exercise treadmill tests for uncomplicated syncope (95% CI 10%-28%). Cardiologists ordered more cardiological tests than internists for noncritical scenarios, such as exercise treadmill tests for uncomplicated syncope.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: