Key result
Transesophageal Doppler and transthoracic impedance fail to reliably estimate cardiac output compared to thermodilution.
Why the study?
The utility and reliability of noninvasive cardiac output measurement methods compared to thermodilution in anesthetized patients were uncertain.
Do transesophageal Doppler and transthoracic impedance accurately measure and track cardiac output compared to pulmonary artery thermodilution in anesthetized patients?
Observational (n=9)
Do transesophageal Doppler and transthoracic impedance accurately measure and track cardiac output compared to pulmonary artery thermodilution in anesthetized patients?
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Transesophageal Doppler and transthoracic impedance are not reliable alternatives to pulmonary artery thermodilution for estimating or tracking cardiac output in anesthetized patients.
Simultaneous intraoperative measurements of cardiac output were obtained in nine patients with transesophageal Doppler, transthoracic impedance, and pulmonary artery thermodilution techniques to evaluate the utility of the noninvasive methods. Pairs of noninvasive and thermodilution measurements were obtained 25 times with transesophageal Doppler and 58 times with transthoracic impedance. Correlation of the noninvasive measurements with thermodilution was poor, with r = 0.43 for transthoracic impedance and r = .68 for transesophageal Doppler. The average difference between the noninvasive and the thermodilution values was -0.4 +/- 1.4 L/min (mean +/- SD) and -0.1 +/- 1.6 L/min for impedance and Doppler, respectively. Changes in cardiac output at sequential time points as measured by thermodilution were predicted with 95% confidence only when a change of >4 L/min was observed by transesophageal Doppler or >8 L/min was observed by transthoracic impedance. Therefore, it is concluded that neither noninvasive technique reliably estimated cardiac output as determined by thermodilution, and neither tracked trends.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Siegel et al. (1988) conducted an observational in Anesthetized patients (n=9). Transesophageal Doppler and transthoracic impedance vs. Pulmonary artery thermodilution was evaluated on Correlation of noninvasive cardiac output measurements with thermodilution (r = 0.43 (impedance) and r = 0.68 (Doppler)). Transesophageal Doppler and transthoracic impedance correlated poorly with thermodilution and failed to reliably estimate cardiac output or track trends.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: