Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
In online shopping contexts, chatbot avatars with human-like features can conform to or conflict with users' contextual role expectations - schemas of what a salesperson in a given retail domain should look like. However, whether users' actual avatar preferences align with their articulated role expectations, and whether avatar–context congruence translates into stronger engagement intentions, remains unclear. In a large-scale between-subjects experiment (N = 5278; data collected 2024 in the United States, United Kingdom, and Switzerland), participants encountered a shopping chatbot in either a wine or a fashion context under one of three avatar-assignment protocols: stereotype-congruent, stereotype-violating, or self-selected. The eight AI-generated humanoid avatars varied in gender expression (male vs. female), age appearance (young vs. old), and clothing style (formal vs. informal). Articulated role expectations diverged sharply across contexts: 41% of participants described the prototypical wine salesperson as older, formally dressed, and male, whereas the modal description in the fashion context was younger, informally dressed, and female. Yet when free to choose, only 10% selected the wine-prototypical avatar, revealing a pronounced expectation–choice gap of 31 percentage points. Though effects were small, schema-congruent avatars elicited higher behavioral intention than schema-violating ones (Δ ≈ 0.15 on a 1–6 scale), while self-selection cushioned mismatches without outperforming well-chosen defaults. Perceived avatar sympathy emerged as the central evaluative pathway, mediating the effect of avatar assignment on behavioral intention and raising explained variance from R2 = .025 to .150. The findings extend the CASA paradigm via schema- and role-congruity accounts and suggest that effective shopping chatbot design combines context-appropriate defaults, sympathy-driven optimization, and opt-in personalization.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Ackermann et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: