Key result
Absolute 99Tcm-DMSA uptake shows no correlation with renal obstruction, though geometric mean methods prove most accurate.
Why the study?
Accurate methods for measuring relative and absolute 99Tcm-DMSA uptake in normal and obstructed kidneys were not well established.
Observational (n=25)
Geometric mean methods are more accurate for calculating absolute 99Tcm-DMSA renal uptake, which does not correlate with the degree of renal obstruction.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Questions utility of absolute 99Tcm-DMSA uptake for grading obstruction; supports geometric mean for quantification and warrants prospective validation.
Relative and absolute 99Tcm-DMSA uptake measurements were carried out on 25 adult patients among whom there were 23 normal and 25 malfunctioning kidneys. Data were collected at 3 and 6 h post intravenous tracer injection. Four methods of calculating absolute uptake were investigated and evaluated. These were based on: (1) posterior view and measured kidney depth; (2) posterior view and Raynauld's depth; (3) geometric mean assuming kidney thickness is small enough not to introduce self attenuation of counts in the kidney itself; (4) geometric mean taking kidney thickness into account. Whilst (1) and (2) were found to overestimate and underestimate renal uptake by up to 5 and 14%, respectively, (3) and (4) were found to be more accurate and comparable. The measurement of relative DMSA uptake (right to left) showed no change between the 1 and 6 h measurements for both obstructed and non-obstructed kidneys. Based on the results from method 4, the absolute renal DMSA uptake had a mean value of 25.4%, S.D. 8.9% and 30.0%, S.D. 9.2% at 3 and 6 h, respectively, for normal/non obstructed kidneys. For obstructed kidneys (responding to frusemide), the mean uptake was 23.0%, S.D. 7.2 and 25.6%, S.D. 6.7% at 3 and 6 h, respectively. For obstructed kidneys not responding to frusemide, the mean uptake was 16.8%, S.D. 3.9 and 20.6%, S.D. 4.8% at 3 and 6 h, respectively. No correlation was found between absolute DMSA uptake and degree of renal obstruction.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
M-C. et al. (1987) conducted an observational in normal and obstructed kidneys (n=25). 99Tcm-DMSA uptake measurement vs. Normal kidneys was evaluated on Absolute renal DMSA uptake. Absolute 99Tcm-DMSA uptake showed no correlation with the degree of renal obstruction, with geometric mean methods providing the most accurate calculations.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: