Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Dear Editor, Melanoma of the oral mucosa is a rare condition and lip melanoma is even rarer. Lip melanoma has been reported to behave aggressively and to be usually encountered at an advanced stage at diagnosis.1 However, in-depth understanding of lip melanoma is limited due to extreme rarity. Therefore, the disease is commonly misdiagnosed and patients with an initial misdiagnosis are more likely to die.2 Herein, we report a case of mucosal lentiginous melanoma of the upper lip over the long term. A 72-year-old Korean male presented with a pigmented patch on the upper lip in July 2009. He recalled that the 1-cm pigmented macule had been on his upper lip for 10 years and had gradually increased in size. He received renal transplantation and subsequent immunosuppression in 2006 and the lesion had abruptly grown in size. Physical examination revealed a 5.2 cm × 4.7 cm asymmetrical pigmented patch with an irregular border and color variegation located on the inner labial mucosa, the cutaneous side of the upper lip, and perioral skin (Fig. 1). The gingiva and maxilla were spared. No lymph node enlargement was detected. He was taking medication for hypertension and diabetes, and was on prednisolone plus cyclosporine immunosuppression therapy. He had a 10-pack-year smoking history, but had stopped smoking 4 years before presentation. There was no family history of melanoma. A punch biopsy had been performed at another clinic before he was referred to us for further evaluation. The specimen demonstrated lentiginous proliferation and a single arrangement of melanocytes without prominent atypism. No dermal invasion was observed. We provisionally diagnosed early mucosal lentiginous melanoma in situ after integrating clinical and histopathological findings, and referred him to oral surgeons for complete excision. However, oral surgeons withheld surgery because they regarded the lesion as a benign lentiginous proliferation of melanocytes based on a formal report issued by oral histopathologists. In February 2010, the patient revisited the oral surgeons with a 6-mm dome-shaped nodule on the upper lip with a surrounding pigmented patch spreading with continuity. An incisional biopsy of the nodule revealed a well-circumscribed melanoma with an invasion depth of 4 mm. Whole body fusion positron emission tomography, bone scan and magnetic resonance imaging failed to reveal any evidence of metastasis. Surgical excision with a 5-mm margin and split thickness skin grafting were done in March 2010. Serial sections of the excised specimen showed intraepidermal proliferation of atypical melanocytes with irregular shapes and large nuclei (Fig. 2). In April 2010, cervical lymph node enlargement was observed and a biopsy demonstrated malignant melanoma. He was then referred to physicians and currently he is being treated with multi-agent chemotherapy (cisplatin, vinblastine and dacarbazine). Asymmetrical brown to black patch with an irregular border and color variegation on the cutaneous side of the upper lip, (a) perioral skin and (b) inner labial mucosa. (a) Histopathological slide of a sample taken in March 2010, revealing intraepidermal lentiginous proliferation of atypical melanocytes corresponding to mucosal lentiginous melanoma in situ, and (b) the higher magnification view of atypical melanocytes with irregular shapes and large nuclei (hematoxylin–eosin, original magnifications: [a] ×200; [b] ×400). Melanomas of oral mucosa are uncommon and most occur on the anterior maxillary gingival area. The lip is the least likely location of oral mucosal melanomas.3 Therefore, lip melanomas are extremely rare and account for only 0.2–0.3% of all melanomas.1,4 Due to its rarity, our understanding of lip melanoma is limited to several case reports and small case series. Lip melanoma is generally observed in the fifth and sixth decades of life, and show a slight male predominance. Variable etiological factors are suggested, but none of them have been proven yet. As in cutaneous melanoma, it has been suggested that mucosal melanomas can manifest as pigmented patches with variable shades, a diameter of more than 6 mm and an irregular shape.5 It is important to perform a biopsy on any suspicious lesion if the clinical diagnosis is in question. If possible, excisional biopsy with a narrow margin is recommended because a small specimen can result in misdiagnosis or a delayed diagnosis. However, some melanomas may progress through an early stage that does not display worrisome features.6 Close follow up and repeated biopsy should be considered for early equivocal lesions to make an accurate diagnosis. Also, dermoscopic algorithms for pigmented skin lesions can be applied to mucosal lesions with high sensitivity and specificity, which can aid early diagnosis of mucosal melanomas.7 In the present case, misdiagnosis based upon an incomplete specimen delayed timely management. Furthermore, had the lesion been completely excised before the vertical growth phase and its acquisition of metastatic potential, our patient would have had a better prognosis. Saida et al.5 reviewed 55 mucosal malignant melanomas. They did not observe any residual component of a melanocytic nevus or melanotic macule and all lesions of invasive melanoma were attached to the overlying epithelium. Therefore, it was suggested that the vast majority of mucosal melanomas are derived from melanocytes located at the epithelial–lamina propria junction, and that pigmented macules preceding melanomas are not benign but rather evolving lesions of mucosal melanoma in situ. In our case, when we scanned the whole structure of the completely excised specimen in serial sections, no evidence of a melanocytic nevus or dysplastic nevus was observed. Accordingly, we believe that the slowly growing persistent pigmented patch in our patient was an unrecognized de novo mucosal lentiginous melanoma in situ. The most common histopathological subtype of lip melanoma in Western countries is superficial spreading melanoma,4 whereas in Asia mucosal lentiginous melanoma is more common.5 In a previous case report of lentigo maligna melanoma of the face showing similar cutaneous lesions to our case, the disease spread from the face onto oral mucosa, including labial mucosa. However, our case corresponded to mucosal lentiginous melanoma and the lesion started from the upper lip, which is less damaged by sunlight than the lower lip. Lip melanomas have been known to behave aggressively. Most lesions were found in an advanced stage except for only a few cases of lip melanoma in situ.4,5 However, it may be due to delayed diagnosis rather than to any intrinsic biological difference between melanomas on the lips and those on the other sites. We believe that all mucosal melanomas exhibit the in situ phase during the early disease stage and that the following vertical growth phase can obliterate in situ lesions. Our case is noteworthy because it suggests that lip melanoma can follow an indolent course with a long radial growth phase, and that its prognosis can be considerably improved if it is detected early and appropriately managed.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Park et al. (2012) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: