Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The hearables market is growing as consumers become more aware of the product, but are clinics ready to handle the demand? The co-design workshop presented in this article provides a model for involving stakeholders in the design process and resulted in the identification of key areas for improving service delivery for hearables. The workshop demonstrated the potential of selling hearables via the clinic website and outlined the considerations that need to be addressed to ensure a successful launch and ongoing operation. By engaging stakeholders and adopting human-centered design principles and the design thinking process, service delivery models for hearables can be developed that meet the needs of all parties involved.www.shutterstock.com. Hearables, delivery model.Hearing aids, hearables, personal sound amplification devices (PSAPs), and sound amplifiers. Adapted from Manchaiah, 2022, with permission. Hearables, delivery model.Potential pathways via which hearables could be dispensed within a hearing clinic, developed based on our previous focus group and behavioral observation studies. Hearables, delivery model.Revised potential pathways via which hearables could be dispensed within a hearing clinic. The information provided in boxes with solid lines is based on our previous focus group and behavioral observation studies. The information provided in boxes with dotted lines was developed by the participants in this workshop. The circles represent the number of votes indicating the sections of the pathway most requiring attention. Hearables, delivery model.DEVICES AND SALES MODELS Hearing aids, hearables, personal sound amplification devices (PSAPs), and sound amplifiers are all designed to help people hear better, but with differences in terms of features and regulatory requirements 1 (Figure 12). Hearing aids are medical devices that are typically prescribed and fitted by an audiologist or hearing aid dispenser. They are designed to amplify sounds to improve audibility and speech understanding for people with hearing loss. They are often programed to an individual’s specific hearing needs and can include features like noise reduction, directional microphones, and feedback cancelation. Hearables are devices that combine some of the functions of a hearing aid with those of a consumer wearable and are not regulated as medical devices. They can be used to stream music, answer phone calls, and track fitness data in addition to enhancing sound. PSAPs are similar to hearing aids in that they amplify sound, but are not regulated as medical devices and are intended for people with normal or near-normal hearing who want to enhance their listening experience in certain situations, such as watching TV or listening to a lecture. They are not designed to manage hearing loss. Sound amplifiers are the most basic type of device and are not regulated as medical devices. They simply amplify sound, often indiscriminately, with little to no processing or adjustment for specific listening environments or hearing needs. There are three general types of sales models for these devices: traditional practitioner-delivered, over-the-counter (OTC), and direct-to-consumer (DTC). Traditional practitioner-delivered models involve visiting an audiologist or hearing aid dispenser for a hearing assessment, discussion of intervention options, fitting with the appropriate device/s if indicated, and follow-up support at varying intervals. 3,4 OTC product sales are available without a prescription and can be provided alongside evaluation and support by a hearing care professional. DTC products are sold directly to consumers through online retailers or other channels, without any hearing professional evaluation or guidance. While audiology clinics have traditionally focused on selling prescription hearing aids, some clinicians are now exploring ways to incorporate self-fitting hearing aids, hearables and PSAP products into their service delivery models. 3 In particular, audiologists might consider how OTC and DTC sales models might complement or supplement the services they currently offer to patients. THE AGE OF HEARABLES When hearables first hit the market, there appeared to be two schools of thought. Opinions within the audiology community varied about the potential impact of these newer products and the OTC and DTC sales models, ranging from “doom and gloom” to recognition of a significant opportunity. 5 Concerns have been raised, including that: hearables may pose a danger to patients who might purchase devices inappropriate for their hearing needs 1,2 patients might have negative experiences, which could further delay seeking help for hearing aids 1 hearable sales might cannibalize hearing aid sales and place financial pressures on clinics 5 audiologists might become obsolete as consumers purchase direct from manufacturers. 6 However, those in support of these products voice potential benefits, including: increased accessibility due to convenience 1 availability of low-cost products opening accessibility and addressing affordability for low-income earners 7 availability of products specifically designed for minimal hearing difficulties, thus opening the market to those who previously were not eligible or had rejected hearing aids 8,9 the potential for hearables to function as a gateway product, encouraging people to adopt hearing intervention earlier. 1,10 Despite the initial buzz surrounding hearables, the market for these products took longer than expected to gain traction, with several false starts along the way. Although some well-known brands like Bose, Sennheiser, and Apple entered the market with direct-to-consumer (DTC) models, their products did not sell as well as anticipated. 11 Research has shown that many people find it difficult to set up and use hearing devices on their own. 12,13 Given that the aforementioned brands adopted a DTC sales model, device management issues or consumer hesitation due to perceived potential for device management issues may explain why hearables were not as successful as expected. These challenges in the hearables market suggest that there may be an important role for the audiologist to play when it comes to nonprescription products, such as hearables. CONSUMER VS. AUDIOLOGIST ATTITUDES TOWARD HEARABLES There are a number of articles to help audiologists understand the strengths and limitations of hearables, with a particular emphasis on OTC and DTC models. 2,6,8 However, there has been less attention on how one might incorporate hearable products into an established audiology service delivery model. 3 Our preliminary research (Bothe et al., in prep) suggests that clinicians feel some reservation toward and uncertainty about hearables and their place in audiology practice, despite viewing them as a useful tool. The kind of issues that are likely to arise from offering hearables in audiology clinics are the time that staff spend discussing hearable options, fitting the hearables and providing troubleshooting support, coupled with the low profit margins afforded by hearable products. This article serves as a discussion piece to help hearing clinic owners and clinicians consider possible ways to incorporate hearables within a traditional hearing service delivery model. We conducted a series of four research studies exploring consumers’ and audiologists’ needs relating to adoption of hearables. We updated a systematic review by Maidment et al. (2018) 14 that compared the effectiveness of PSAPs, hearables and other alternative listening devices to conventional hearing aids for adults with hearing loss. The key findings (Maidment et al., in press) showed that alternative devices were better than remaining unaided, although other relative benefits were dependent on whether the device was ‘basic’ or ‘premium’ based on the cost of device and the level of technology. We conducted focus groups with 1.) adults who had hearing difficulties but who were not hearing aid owners, and 2.) audiologists, with the aim to explore what stakeholders want and need from hearables. We showed that adults with hearing difficulties desired trusted audiological support when considering hearables, as well as trusted information on cost, function, and quality (Bothe et al., in prep). Whereas audiologists expressed uncertainty about hearables, and need to develop effective methods to engage with patients about these products. A behavioral observation study explored what the hearables journey looks like, from information seeking, selection, and purchase through to self-fitting (Ferguson et al., in prep). Video-recorded think-aloud sessions with adults with hearing difficulties were used to observe 1.) how they searched for information about hearables online, and 2.) how they set up and started to use a hearable without audiologist guidance. Most, but not all, participants experienced some difficulties with setting up the hearables themselves and asked the research team for assistance. A workshop based on design thinking principles 15 was run to explore what service delivery for hearables might look like within a traditional hearing services organization. The findings from the fourth study are the focus of this -article. WHAT DOES A HEARABLE SERVICE DELIVERY MODEL LOOK LIKE? We sought to co-design a service delivery model for an established audiology clinic by engaging a diverse range of stakeholders (e.g., patients, health care clinicians) to provide valuable and informed perspectives and insights. We drew on human-centered design principles 16 that focus on the needs, wants, and limitations of the end-user. Human-centered design principles involve understanding the user’s perspective and designing solutions that are tailored to their needs and improve their overall experience. The goal of human-centered design is to create products and services that are both useful and usable for the target audience, considering the context in which they will be used. One approach that is increasingly used in audiology research 15, is the design thinking process 17, a problem-solving approach that involves empathy, experimentation, and iteration to arrive at creative and effective solutions. Design thinking follows a seven-step process: empathize, define, ideate, prototype, test, iterate, and implement. This study focused on ideation: generating a wide range of ideas and potential solutions, encouraging open-ended thinking, and considering solutions that might seem unconventional or outside the box. The aim of the workshop was to develop a co-designed prototype model of service delivery for selling hearables within a longstanding, established hearing clinic that would be tailored to the needs of patients and improve their overall experience. This could then be evaluated subsequently. TOWARD A SERVICE DELIVERY MODEL Nine stakeholder representatives (three adults with hearing difficulties, two clinical audiologists, two client liaison staff, and two clinic managers) attended the design thinking workshop, which was moderated by the authors. At the start of the session, a 10-minute presentation shared the results of our first three studies, encouraging discussion on the key findings. The potential pathways via which hearables could be dispensed within a hearing clinic based on the rich data from our previous focus group and behavioral observation studies were presented on large, wall-mounted sheets of paper (Figure 2). Workshop participants were invited to discuss these potential pathways, and add any additional -options not recorded and/or change the wording of existing options. We then presented workshop attendees with comments made by individual participants from our previous studies relating to hearables service delivery. For example, “I would like a trial period to test functionality,” or “My product selection would be guided by confidence in the service and recommendations by the audiologist.” Each participant took a random pile of five printed comments and stuck them onto the relevant part of the potential pathway mapped on the wall in response to the question, “Where do these patient needs and wants fit within the service delivery pathway?” This process helped the group visualize which parts of the pathway were “hot topics” for the participants in the previous studies. Workshop participants were then asked to think about whether there were any key considerations missing, and if so, they were invited to write these onto sticky notes and add them to the wall. The group was then invited to consider the pathway as a whole, and to discuss where the opportunities for improved service delivery for hearables might lay. Participants were asked to look at the collage of potential pathways they had created and to consider which points in the potential pathway most required attention. Participants were asked to nominate three problem areas by placing sticky dots onto that section of the potential pathways, thereby identifying points in the pathway that most requiring attention (Figure 3). Finally, we moved into the brainstorming phase of the workshop. Participants were split into two groups. Each group was asked to select one of the top three points in the pathway most requiring attention and to brainstorm the kinds of things that might help solve the problems and enhance the clinic’s service delivery model relating to hearables. Group One tackled the problems around “Purchasing hearables through the clinic website.” They posited that selling hearables via the clinic website would be a great opportunity to expand the business and reach a wider audience, and they outlined important considerations to ensure a successful launch and ongoing operation, including: identification of regulatory requirements for selling hearables in their region and ensuring that clinics comply with all applicable laws and regulations website design—building an easy-to-use web portal that provides information about hearable features, benefits, and pricing, and allows customers to compare and purchase hearables online consideration of financial implications of selling hearables OTC, within the clinic, or DTC via the clinic website, including the costs associated with purchasing and stocking hearables, as well as the potential revenue from online sales the need to develop internal procedures for supporting both online and in-person customers, including hiring additional staff, training staff on how to fit and program hearables, and implementing a system for tracking customer purchases and support requests developing a marketing strategy to promote their hearable service offering ensuring that they have the resources to provide adequate customer support, such as online support through a chatbot or email, as well as offering phone support during business hours carefully selecting the hearables clinic’s offer on their website, considering the needs of their target market, and keeping up with new products as they enter the market. Group Two tackled the problems around “The need for hearing assessment and discussion on range of devices available.” The key issues noted by this group included: the need to establish what existing technology patients have (e.g., hearing devices, mobile phones) the need to establish patients’ digital literacy the audiologists’ ability to explain the pros and cons of hearing aids vs. hearables, as well as the different types of hearables available the ability to explain the cost-benefit of specific hearable devices being able to explain the clinics’ offerings relating to hearables, including the cost of devices, support and aftercare. Group Two developed a prototype of a clinical tool to assist discussion and shared decision making relating to hearable selection. Shared decision-making is a collaborative process that involves gathering information, weighing benefits and risks, and making informed choices about care. It empowers patients to be active participants in their own treatment, considering personal preferences, values, and goals. In a separate grant-funded research study we are developing an online decision support intervention (HearChoice) to support informed, patient-centered decision-making 18, which will include many of these aspects. In conclusion, the co-design workshop involving stakeholders provided potential pathways for the delivery of hearables through an established audiology clinic, and identified key areas for improving service delivery for hearables. The workshop demonstrated the potential of selling hearables via the clinic website and outlined the considerations that need to be addressed to ensure a successful launch and ongoing operation. By engaging stakeholders and adopting human-centered design principles and the design thinking process, service delivery models for hearables can be developed that meet the needs of all parties involved. Thoughts on something you read here? Write to us at [email protected].
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Bennett et al. (2023) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: