Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
A recent article by Scotland et al. (2003; hereafter referred to as SEA) purporting to examine the value of morphological data in phylogeny reconstruction has been received critically by several systematists (Jenner, 2004; Wiens, 2004). As paleontologists—and in an area of systematics restricted solely to morphological data—we take exception to many of the arguments put forward by SEA and feel we may provide a unique perspective in the debate. In their paper, SEA argued for a redefined role for morphology in phylogeny reconstruction, one in which “rigorous and critical anatomical studies of fewer morphological characters, in the context of molecular phylogenies, is a more fruitful approach to integrating the strengths of morphological data with those of sequence data” (p. 539). Such a statement is bold and therefore warrants a critical analysis, as it would effectively neuter the ability of morphological data to generate novel phylogenies. Though issues such as accuracy, support, character coding, and character conceptualization were discussed by SEA, in all cases these discussions resorted to a “too few characters” argument. As the authors characterized it, the “main constraint of morphology-based phylogenetic inference concerns the limited number of unambiguous characters available for analysis in a transformational framework” (p. 539). Additionally, the merits of increased taxon sampling in the context of morphological data were discussed by SEA, and found to be lacking.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Smith et al. (2005) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: