Key result
CODESNA_HRV reliably assesses resting autonomic tone in athletes with ~1-10% variability, but misses acute tilt changes.
Why the study?
A new tool, CODESNA_HRV, was developed to analyze heart rate variability for assessing autonomic nervous system activity, requiring evaluation of its reliability and sensitivity.
Does CODESNA_HRV software reliably assess autonomic nervous system activity from heart rate variability compared to traditional indices?
Cross-Sectional (n=25)
No
Does CODESNA_HRV software reliably assess autonomic nervous system activity from heart rate variability compared to traditional indices?
CODESNA_HRV is a reliable tool for assessing chronic autonomic nervous system adaptations from heart rate variability, though it may lack sensitivity for detecting acute changes.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Should not yet alter clinical HRV use; leaves open CODESNA_HRV utility pending patient validation.
To test CODESNA_HRV, a new tool dedicated to the analysis of heart rate variability (HRV).This software computed indices aimed at evaluating the parasympathetic and sympathetic cardiac control.Control subjects performed three active tilt-tests (8 min supine, 7 min standing, separated by 15 min) to test the reliability.They also performed a passive tilt test (8 min at 0, 30, 45 and 60°) to evaluate whether the indices highlighted subtle autonomic nervous system (ANS) changes.Finally, Controls were compared to Runners to evaluate whether an endurance training effect could be observed.Fifteen control subjects (22 ± 1 years, 177 ± 7 cm, 70 ± 6kg) and 10 high-level runners (28 ± 7 years, 180 ± 8 cm, and 71 ± 4kg) For each condition, the CODESNA_HRV indices were calculated and compared to the traditional time-and frequency-domain HRV indices calculated in accordance with the 1996 Task Force (using Kubios software).Additionally, during the passive tilt-test, 4 different durations were used for the CODESNA_HRV analysis to assess whether changing the duration modified the indices.Results indicated that CODESNA_HRV was reliable (coefficient of variation ranging 1-10%).Changes from parasympathetic predominance when supine to sympathetic predominance when standing could not be clearly detected with CODESNA_HRV during the tilt-tests.Runners had a clear parasympathetic cardiac predominance compared to controls.This suggests that chronic changes could be highlighted by CODESNA_HRV but more studies are needed for evaluation of acute changes.One advantage of CODESNA_HRV is that the duration of the analysed period could be changed without major impact on the indices calculated, yielding a more flexible usability.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Laurent Mourot (2018) conducted a cross-sectional in Healthy subjects and endurance runners (n=25). CODESNA_HRV software vs. Kubios software (1996 Task Force standards) was evaluated on Reliability of CODESNA_HRV indices (coefficient of variation) (CV 1-10%). CODESNA_HRV provided reliable heart rate variability indices that highlighted chronic parasympathetic predominance in athletes, though acute autonomic changes during tilt-tests were less clearly detected.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: