Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
“Regional anaesthesia always works—provided you put the right dose of the right drug in the right place” 1. This insightful quote from Denny and Harrop-Griffiths reveals a universally attractive simplicity inherent in regional anaesthesia. The apparent simplicity in their statement, however, shrouds the true complexity of two interrelated variables: ‘right dose’ and ‘right place’. An early report of peripheral nerve block for upper limb surgery appeared in 1885. William Stewart Halsted performed an upper limb block by soaking the surpaclavicular brachial plexus with cocaine under direct vision 2. In this landmark report, open surgical dissection facilitated deposition of local anaesthetic in ‘the right place’. With the advantage of hindsight, it is now evident that cocaine was very obviously not the ‘right drug’ for regional anaesthesia. Irrespective of its psychoactive effects and the potential for addiction, cardiovascular complications limit the use of cocaine as a local anaesthetic 3. The local anaesthetic effect of cocaine requires the administration of relatively high doses. Centrally mediated sympathomimetic effects (increased brainstem outflow, with enhanced adrenergic receptor sensitivity to noradrenaline) occur even at low doses, and therefore the likelihood of adverse cardiovascular effects during regional anaesthesia using cocaine is high. Although Halsted may not have been the first to report the use of cocaine as a local anaesthetic 4, this form of anaesthesia grew in popularity in tandem with the availability of hollow-bore needles for hypodermic administration. An art form consisting of elegant, percutaneous nerve localisation techniques subsequently evolved, and with them the subspecialty of regional anaesthesia came into being. ‘Traditional’ peripheral nerve block techniques, which have stood the test of time, involve the blind advancement of needles toward the presumed location of target nerves. Surrogate markers of the needle tip's location, such as distal sensory (paraesthesia) or motor (muscle twitch) responses, are used to indicate needle placement in the desired position. A widely quoted edict, ‘no paresthesia, no anaesthesia’ 5, 6, is tacit acknowledgement that close proximity is required between the needle and nerve to put the drug ‘in the right place’. The most critical limitation of blind nerve localisation techniques is identifying the precise relationship between the needle's tip and target nerve immediately before the injection of local anaesthetic. Large injectate volume (large being a term relative to the surface area of the target nerve(s)) has been historically used to overcome this limitation. Conventional wisdom suggests that a block needle placed in the general vicinity of target nerves would allow successful peripheral nerve block, so long as a sufficiently large volume of local anaesthetic is administered. Local anaesthetic dosing in peripheral nerve block is based upon the principle of maximal allowable dose. A maximal allowable dose may be calculated and diluted into a large, convenient-to-administer volume (usually 30–40 ml). Large-volume peripheral nerve block using the maximal allowable dose may achieve the desired outcome successfully, but systemic absorption and unintentional intravascular injection of such solutions have been reported, with serious and catastrophic consequences 7-10. Recent reports of nerve injuries and systemic toxicity in large prospective registries indicate that adverse patient outcome following peripheral nerve block is directly related to high doses of local anaesthetic 11, 12. Systemic toxicity is a dose-dependent phenomenon, therefore limiting the dose of local anaesthetic should lessen the risk of toxicity. The relationship between dose of local anaesthetic and nerve injury is somewhat unclear; however, the Dartmouth registry is of particular concern, as all reported nerve injuries followed the injection of 30 ml of a solution containing the maximal allowable dose 12. Ultrasonography has re-introduced sighted deposition of local anaesthetic to the practice of peripheral nerve block, thereby allowing direct observation of the needle, target nerve(s) and local anaesthetic injectate. Thus, non-invasive visual confirmation of ‘drug in the right place’ is possible. Precise perineural placement of the needle and local anaesthetic injectate has resulted in reports of successful peripheral nerve block using small doses of local anaesthetic 13-17. These, and other reports, have fuelled the debate regarding the optimal dose of local anaesthetic for successful ultrasound-guided peripheral nerve block. In this issue of Anaesthesia, the topic of minimal effective dose and ultrasound-guided femoral nerve block is further explored. Taha and Abd-Elmaksoud 18 report a study to identify the 90% effective concentration of 15 ml ropivacaine injectate in ultrasound-guided femoral nerve block for major knee surgery. This study is impressive in that it reports the results of blocks on patients undergoing major knee joint surgery using exclusively regional anaesthesia. Given the complex innervation of the knee, and the number of nerves that must be blocked, limitation of the dose of local anaesthetic is of particular importance. Also in this issue, Watson et al. 19 report a study to identify the 50% and 95% effective concentration of 30 ml levobupivacaine injectate, in analgesic ultrasound-guided femoral nerve block for fractured neck of femur. These reports add important new information to aid clinicians in selecting the appropriate local anaesthetic dose for femoral nerve block. In considering whether the results of these studies may be directly translated into clinical use, the study methodology used in both is deserving of comment. The up-and-down study design is a staircase methodology, initially used in explosives research, and adapted for use in clinical dose-finding studies. This study design is useful in characterising specific dose-response relationships while minimising the number of study subjects required. When used in dose-finding studies, the amount of drug administered is determined by the response of the preceding study subject: if the predefined ‘response’ is not achieved, the next subject receives a greater dose/amount, while if the response is achieved, the next subject receives less 20. Sequential dosing is essentially based upon two study strategies. A predetermined dosing increment may be used, in which dosing intervals are based upon a known (or estimated) standard deviation of dose-response in a similar study population. This strategy is particularly effective for estimating the median dose (or amount) of drug that produces a defined effect in half of the subjects who receive it (the ED50). Unfortunately knowing the ED50 of a population is of little clinical use, as individual patients do not have an ED50. From this point estimate, the ED95 (the dose/amount that produces the effect in 95% of recipients) can be calculated. Watson et al. 19 employed this strategy to measure the ED50 of levobupivacaine, using probit regression to calculate the ED95. Taha and Abd-Elmaksoud 18, in contrast, employed a probability-based sequential dosing strategy. Using this methodology, a successful block resulted in subsequent patients' receiving either: (i) the same ropivacaine concentration, the probability of which was 0.89; or (ii) a concentration of 0.02% w/v less, with a probability of 0.11. While this adds to the complexity of the study design, it allows the direct calculation of the local anaesthetic's ED90, which is arguably a clinically more relevant estimate of minimal effective dose than ED50. Of note, Taha and Abd-Elmaksoud's study gives us a figure of 25 mg for the ED90 of ropivacaine (calculated from the measured minimal effective anaesthetic concentration90 with a fixed 15-ml injection) 18, considerably less than Casati et al.'s figure for ED95 of 75 mg (derived from measurement of minimal effective anaesthetic volume50 with a 0.5% solution) 17. This may be accounted for by differences in both the study methodologies and, perhaps importantly, the peripheral nerve block techniques used. In considering the optimal dose of local anaesthetic, it is important to understand what exactly local anaesthetics must do to achieve their desired effect. Local anaesthetics are tertiary amine bases that reversibly bind the interior of transmembrane sodium receptors. Inhibition of transmembrane sodium flux prevents depolarisation and thereby impairs nerve impulse propagation. It has been demonstrated that successful peripheral nerve block requires blockade of more than 70% of the transmembrane sodium channel population over three consecutive nodes of Ranvier 21. Mammalian inter-nodal distance ranges from 200 μm to 2000 μm, and is determined principally by the diameter of the nerve fibre 22. Therefore, the administration of a volume of local anaesthetic sufficient to cover more than 6 mm of nerve, with sufficient molecules to block 70% of the sodium channels, will block impulse propagation. Given that sodium channel density, subtype and sensitivity to blockade are determined by a myriad of genetic and environmental factors, it is likely that significant inter-individual variability exists as to the number of local anaesthetic molecules required to achieve adequate impairment of impulse propagation along a peripheral nerve. Significant differences exist in nerve architecture and structure between nerve roots and peripheral nerves 23. This structural variation may also influence the minimal effective local anaesthetic dose at different sites of peripheral nerve block. The concept of local anaesthetic dose's influencing both the success and the duration of peripheral nerve block has been topical for some time. The interrelationship between injectate volume, local anaesthetic concentration and the duration of conduction block has been studied with conflicting results 24-27. It is intuitive that there may be a direct relationship between the success and duration of a block and the total local anaesthetic dose. The assumption made is that more favourable peripheral nerve block characteristics might be achieved by increasing the volume and/or the concentration of drug. The evidence for this assumption is far from conclusive. Some authors have reported longer-lasting sensory and motor block when using higher doses of local anaesthetic, and suggest that the additional analgesia provided by the sensory block warrants the use of higher local anaesthetic doses 24, 25. Other studies find no meaningful difference in block characteristics 26, 27. The key consideration in selecting an appropriate dose of local anaesthetic is achieving successful anaesthesia while minimising the likelihood of adverse patient outcomes. The true benefit of any additional short period of sensory block in the context of an appropriately resourced and structured postoperative environment remains unclear. In the reports by Taha and Abd-Elmaksoud 18 and Watson et al. 19, the technical proficiency of the regional anaesthetist in both ultrasonography and peripheral nerve block may have directly influenced the dose of local anaesthetic required to achieve ultrasound guided femoral nerve. Expert practitioners will confidently identify target nerves, place needles in an appropriate place and ensure appropriate spread of local anaesthetic around the nerve. Novice and intermediate regional anaesthetists may not be so skilled, and may lack the cognitive and procedural skills required to perform ultrasound-guided peripheral nerve block using comparatively small doses of local anaesthetic. In interpreting the data presented in both of these reports, it is worth considering that the results obtained may reflect the expertise of the individual practitioners involved, and somewhat limit the external validity of the study outputs. The topic of local anaesthetic dose and successful peripheral nerve block is complex. Many anatomical, physiological, pharmacological and procedural factors determine the likelihood of block success. It is probably too soon to provide an answer to the question: ‘how much is enough?’ Both the reports in this issue of Anaesthesia 18, 19 confirm that a successful block can be achieved with comparatively small doses of local anaesthetic in patients undergoing major surgery, albeit in injectate volumes that are large in relation to the surface area of the target nerve. Undoubtedly, additional work will follow to aid clinicians in protecting patients from the unwanted effects of local anaesthetics. With the advent of sighted needle guidance, the era of blindly injecting the maximal allowable dose of local anaesthetic in a high-volume solution is coming to an end. No external funding and no competing interests declared.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
OʼDonnell et al. (2014) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: