Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Scholarship on urban religious rituals has highlighted their role in augmenting the visibility and empowerment of diverse communities of faith. Yet scholars have expressed scepticism regarding the extent to which such rituals promote durable forms of social recognition, connection, and integration. Although some urban rituals engage a range of participants and audiences, many are akin to what Mario Small has called ‘private public events’, or collective gatherings that, while formally public, are noticed and attended mainly by in-group members. This article critically examines the ‘publicness’ of urban religious rituals and the degree to which they foster durable connections between religious minorities and the wider society. Our empirical analysis centres on Shia ritual processions in Barcelona and Birmingham. We argue that the publicness of these processions varies depending on: 1) structural factors such as the historical trajectory, socioeconomic composition, or spatial positionality of Shia communities in each city; 2) the personal orientations, connections, and capabilities of local Shia leadership; and 3) the institutional orientation of municipal agencies involved in regulating urban religious affairs. We also show how the public dimensions of Shia processions have varied over time due to processes of routinisation, as well as communal differentiation and fragmentation.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Astor et al. (2025) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: