Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Genetic selection presents a long-term opportunity to reduce enteric methane emissions in beef cattle. This study evaluated the effect of incorporating an enteric methane production trait into the Irish Terminal Index, an index that is typical of global terminal-type indexes and quantified its impact on methane output and other economically important traits. At present, the Irish Terminal Index incorporates a Carbon sub-index based on life cycle assessment in an effort to reduce farm carbon emissions. Selection index scenarios were modelled to reflect an index with no environmental consideration, the current status quo, the inclusion of a direct enteric methane trait and finally the impact of changes in carbon pricing. Genetic parameters were derived from a national multi-breed dataset of 1,508 beef animals with enteric methane phenotypes. Selection based on the current index which includes a lifecycle carbon weighting, increased daily enteric methane emissions by up to 2.14 g/day, while the inclusion of a direct enteric methane trait reversed the response, with predicted reductions of 0.22g/day and 4.20 g/day depending on carbon price. Associated changes included a 13.81 kg increase in carcass weight response and a 0.33 kg reduction in feed intake per animal under the highest environmental weighting (Carbon valued at €160/tonne and a direct enteric methane trait). Scaled to the national herd, this would equate to an annual reduction of approximately 27,400 tonnes of carbon dioxide equivalent and an opportunity cost of 1,311 tonnes of carcass output. Selection direction remained favourable across all production traits, with minimal impact on calving, docility, and conformation traits. These results demonstrate that enteric methane can be incorporated into the national breeding goal with measurable reductions in emissions and limited trade-offs in economically relevant performance traits.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Ryan et al. (2025) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: