Key result
Self-paced exercise delays parasympathetic recovery vs constant workload, slowing 60-second heart rate recovery by ~7 bpm.
Why the study?
The effect of constant load versus self-paced endurance exercise with similar total work on autonomic control after exercise was unclear.
Does self-paced exercise compared to constant workload exercise delay parasympathetic activity recovery in physically active men?
Does self-paced exercise compared to constant workload exercise delay parasympathetic activity recovery in physically active men?
Absolute Event Rate: 30% vs 37%
Self-paced endurance exercise delays parasympathetic reactivation compared to constant-load exercise of identical total work.
Delayed parasympathetic reactivation follows self-paced versus constant-load exercise; hypothesis-generating for post-exercise autonomic monitoring in athletes.
The main purpose of this study was to compare the effect of the constant load and self‐paced exercise with similar total work on autonomic control after endurance exercise. Ten physically active men were submitted to (i) a maximal incremental exercise test, (ii) a 4‐km cycling time trial (4‐km TT), and (iii) a constant workload test with identical total external work performed at 4‐km TT. Gas exchange was measured throughout the tests, while blood lactate, heart rate, and heart rate variability (HRV) were measured during the passive recovery. Power output measured at the last lap (i.e. 3600–4000 m) of 4‐km TT (316 ± 89 W) was statistically higher than power output measured at the end of the constant workload exercise (211 ± 42 W). The 4‐km TT produced higher values of blood lactate concentration (8.8 ± 2.1 mmol L−1) than the constant workload test (7.8 ± 2.1 mmol L−1). The heart rate recovery measured at 60 s (constant workload: 37 ± 7 bpm; 4‐km TT: 30 ± 6) and 120 s (constant workload: 57 ± 9 bpm; 4‐km TT: 51 ± 9 bpm) were higher in the constant workload than in the self‐paced exercise. The HRV (i.e. RMSSD30s) was statistically higher in the constant load exercise measured at 120, 420, 450, 480, 540, and 570 s than the self‐paced exercise. These findings suggest that the autonomic control responses were dependent of the endurance exercise modalities, with parasympathetic activity being delayed after self‐paced exercise, as evidenced by post‐exercise heart rate indices.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Trojbicz et al. (2018) studied Healthy (physically active) (n=10). Self-paced exercise (4-km cycling time trial) vs. Constant workload test with identical total external work was evaluated on Heart rate recovery at 60 s (bpm). Self-paced exercise resulted in delayed parasympathetic activity compared to constant workload exercise, evidenced by lower heart rate recovery at 60s (30 vs 37 bpm) and 120s (51 vs 57 bpm).
Synapse has enriched 5 closely related papers on similar clinical questions. Consider them for comparative context: