Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The United Nations declared 2010 to be the International Year of Biodiversity in which everyone should play some part in safeguarding the Earth’s diversity of living organisms. Individuals will have different visions of what constitutes the conservation of biodiversity, ranging from saving iconic species or small patches of species-rich habitat, to saving spatial scales of sufficient size from which the combined activities of the component species derive important ecosystem functions. All of these scales provide targets for conservation, and all can aim for the dual benefit of conserving species and at least some ecosystem characteristics. At large spatial scales there is often an interest in conserving virgin vegetation that has escaped human influences. Rackham (2008) points out, for woodlands at least, and even extending to the Amazon, that such virgin types probably do not exist in climates suitable for human habitation. The human footprint is ubiquitous and has many forms, from direct destruction to global-scale fumigation by oxides of nitrogen and CO2 from industrial activities. These large-scale phenomena can drive changes in biodiversity (Xia & Wan, 2008) and, potentially, in situ evolution (Onoda et al., 2009). The question of exactly what biodiversity should be conserved is difficult to answer, particularly when the biodiversity has rarely been quantified – anywhere. The diversity of flowering plants is easy to see but this can only hint at a much higher belowground diversity. The application of molecular techniques for investigating fungal diversity has been a major boon to those working in soil. Recent work shows that under a temperate forest including oak and beech, as little as 4 g of soil may contain > 2000 species of fungi (Buée et al., 2009; F. Martin pers. comm.), while just the leaves of bur oak may host one-third of this number of species (Jumpponen & Jones, 2009). Perhaps only 1% of this high species diversity dominates numerically, but the cut-off point for identifying important or useful species has no theoretical basis. Global-scale travel of people and plants affects biodiversity by enhancing the geographical spread of many species, which become identified as alien species. Even buried species of ectomycorrhizal fungi highjack rides on plant roots to new locations (Vellinga et al., 2009). These invasive plant species can exert large impacts on major ecosystem functions, such as the carbon and nitrogen cycles (Liao et al., 2008). Deliberate human intervention to replace natural vegetation with crops can be seen as the visible face of biodiversity destruction. Even here there is substantial diversity in the fungal communities of the crops and soil, and this inter-relationship experiences human impacts through different varieties of crops, which differ in their associated fungal diversity (Pan et al., 2008; Saunders & Kohn, 2009). However, the fungal diversity in the crop soil is probably less than one-tenth of that observed under either a mixed temperate forest (Buée et al., 2009), or a wet sclerophyll forest (Tedersoo et al., 2008). The aerial environment (Jumpponen & Jones, 2009), the chemical environment of the soil (Ehinger et al., 2009; Morris et al., 2009) and year-to-year variations in climate (Sthultz et al., 2009), all exert strong influences on the fungal diversity associated with plants, indicating a much faster species turnover and greater variation in diversity than their host plants. Molecular techniques have provided evidence of the large diversity of fungi associated with their host plants and which are largely hidden from general view. Molecular techniques have also been used to uncover the hidden histories of flowering plants, including their genetic responses to changes in geographical ranges, in particular since the last glacial maximum. It is generally considered that genetic diversity of a species declines towards its range limits. This is seen to be the case for the Mediterranean Aleppo pine (Grivet et al., 2009), which is a glacial relict in Greece and the source of less genetically diverse populations that have spread during the Holocene. Conservation of this species should clearly concentrate on populations in Greece. However, Aleppo pine also showed genetic change in response to the new environments encountered during its post-glacial spread, a response also observed for the shorter-lived bladder campion (Keller et al., 2009), inviting the question of which populations, if any, can afford not to be conserved? Generalizing about plant species seems always to lead to the get-out statement that species differ. This is nicely shown by the deerberry (Yakimowski & Eckert, 2008), which showed no decline in genetic diversity towards its range margins, over a large latitudinal range of 37 to 45°N in eastern North America. The responses of plant species and diversity to climatic change have perforce to base future responses on current geographical distributions. The climatic envelope of the currently realized distributions can then be moved geographically in step with a simulated and changing climate. This simple approach misses many key ecological features, such as the dynamics of geographical change and the influences of changing CO2 concentrations, but a key assumption is that the potential range of a species is little different from its realized range. In a phylogeographical study of myrtle beech, Worth et al. (2009) showed that the species withstood extreme aridity during the last glaciation, in climates beyond its currently realized physiologically determined range. In this case at least, the potential and realized distributions and climatic envelopes do not match, casting some doubt on current approaches used to predict future plant distributions. Larger-scale vegetation-based changes in distribution may provide more realistic future projections. The treeless tundra was warmer than the present during the last interglacial (Francis et al., 2006), with a greater extension of the boreal forests and a smaller area for tundra species (Hoffmann & Röser, 2009). This reduction is predicted for a future, warmer world (Woodward & Lomas, 2004), but a simulated increase in biodiversity (Woodward & Kelly, 2008) of boreal species and weeds could seriously change the characteristic biodiversity of the tundra. Tundra species have evolved in parallel from many nonarctic ancestors (Hoffmann & Röser, 2009), suggesting that the necessary functional adaptation is relatively easy but this evolutionary timescale greatly exceeds the timescales considered for future climatic change. The application of molecular approaches to diversity has identified, quantified and qualified long-held hypotheses in a variety of species and geographical locations. The results may help to focus the conservation of biodiversity, although the approaches have not yet reached the stage of identifying which species should be conserved, beyond the inevitable feeling that this should be all species. A genomic comparison of black cottonwood and thale cress (Quesada et al., 2008) provides a further take on this conclusion. It was demonstrated that the marked phenological differences between the two species were caused primarily by differences in the expression of orthologous genes, with the two species sharing > 90% of genes, even after a genetic separation of over 100 million yr. Biodiversity appears to be less about the differences in genes and much more about the regulation of gene expression.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
F. I. Woodward (2010) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: