Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Maternal attachment begins during early pregnancy with thoughts of and feelings for the unborn baby gradually increasing, and attachment intensifying in the first weeks after birth1. The maternal antenatal attachment scale (MAAS)2 was developed to assess maternal emotional attachment to the fetus, and the maternal–infant attachment (MIA) questionnaire3 to assess the attachment between mother and infant post-delivery. The MIA questionnaire has 19 items, is self-reported and has acceptable levels of internal consistency and test–retest reliability; it covers factors including quality of attachment, absence of hostility and pleasure in interaction2. Our earlier work demonstrated that, in the first half of pregnancy, three-dimensional (3D) ultrasound image exposure does not enhance maternal attachment compared with two-dimensional ultrasound image exposure4. The current study was undertaken in third-trimester pregnancies (at the 28–30-week routine scan) to evaluate the effect on maternal attachment of exposure to a real-time four-dimensional (4D) fetal ultrasound video vs 3D ultrasound stills of the fetal face. This was based on a suggestion made by Stuart Campbell1 that providing parents with a video of 4D fetal ultrasound in the third trimester might reinforce maternal attachment. After obtaining ethical approval, 300 women were recruited, of which 150 were randomized to 3D ultrasound image exposure and 150 to 4D ultrasound video exposure. As per study protocol, the exclusion criteria were: fetal abnormality, fetal position that precluded obtaining a 3D image or 4D real-time scan of the face, obstetric and medical complications during pregnancy, existing (diagnosed) mental disorder and 3D group participant having a 4D scan performed elsewhere prior to delivery (exclusion from post-delivery assessments). This study was approved by the local institutional review board and was exempt from ANZCTR (Australia and New Zealand Clinical Trials Registry) registration as it was not a clinical intervention trial. High-resolution 3D and 4D imaging were performed in all participants. Voluson E8 ultrasound machines (GE Medical Systems, Sydney, NSW, Australia) were used and scans were performed by three accredited senior sonographers. After the 28–30-week scan, women in the 3D group were provided with a DVD of six 3D ultrasound stills that were considered to be the best images of the fetal face. Those in the 4D group were given a DVD of approximately 2 minutes' real-time scanning of the fetal face and facial expressions. Participants in both groups were given their DVD after their scan was complete. Stipulating control over how many times the DVD contents were viewed by participants therefore was not possible. The progression of participants through the study is shown in Figure S1. No significant differences were found between the 3D and 4D ultrasound groups in baseline characteristics, including demographic variables. Based on a sample of 147 women who returned the MIA questionnaire post-delivery, there was no statistically significant difference in quality of attachment scores between the groups (Figure 1). Confidence intervals for the plausible difference were within a clinically unimportant range (< 0.5 SD). Our findings do not support the suggested advantage of real-time 4D over still 3D ultrasound for improving the quality of attachment of a mother to her newborn child. Please note: The publisher is not responsible for the content or functionality of any supporting information supplied by the authors. Any queries (other than missing content) should be directed to the corresponding author for the article.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Benzie et al. (2017) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: