Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Management intensive rotational grazing (MIRG) is an expanding practice among dairy farmers in the Upper Midwest. Despite the high productivity associated with MIRG pastures, many acres of unmanaged, continuously grazed pastures still exist. Our goal was to document relationships between forage growth, production, and quality in rotational and continuous grazing systems and to evaluate the role that management plays in the productivity of these pastures. Forages were monitored under farmer management on three MIRG dairy farms and on three continuously grazed pastures (CON) on conventional livestock farms in 1994 and 1995. Evaluation of the results was complicated by the range of conditions and management practices that characterized the study's participants. As is typical for this region, CON pastures in this study were unmanaged. In contrast, MIRG pastures were monitored daily by their owners and sward health was maintained through movement of the herd and such practices as interseeding legumes. Forage mass for MIRG pastures was greater than CON every week of the 24‐wk grazing season, averaging 1763 lb/acre for ready‐to‐graze MIRG paddocks vs. 850 lb/acre for CON. Crude protein averaged 16.6% for MIRG vs. 15.3% for CON. Seasonal average ADF values were 34.2% for MIRG and 34.1% for CON. Average NDF values were 53.4% for MIRG and 56.8% for CON. Forage mass between 1300 and 1900 lb/acre appeared to provide a balance between yield and quality on MIRG pastures. Cooperating farmers most often chose to graze paddocks at this level. For CON, forage quality decreased as forage biomass increased. Ready‐to‐graze MIRG paddocks had significantly higher quality than CON pastures at equivalent levels of forage biomass. It was not possible in this study to isolate individual management practices and test them separately, so no one factor can be viewed as responsible for the differences we observed. Indeed, these differences probably are the result of the interaction among several management practices on MIRG farms and the lack of pasture management on CON farms. Research Question Recent improvements in fencing and watering technology have allowed livestock farmers to maximize the productivity of cool‐season pastures through management intensive rotational grazing (MIRG). As a result, many farmers in the Northeast and North Central regions of the USA are able to produce the bulk of their forage requirements from these rotationally managed pastures. Conversion from confinement‐style livestock production has involved seeding former cropland to pasture grasses and legumes as well as renovation of existing continuously grazed pasture. Many additional acres of underutilized cool‐season pasture exist in eastern USA and Canada and could potentially be made more productive by conversion to MIRG management. The goal of this research was to quantify growth, productivity and forage quality in rotationally managed pasture systems on private farms under farmer management and to compare them with unmanaged continuously grazed pastures on conventional livestock farms. Literature Summary Because MIRG is a relatively new practice among the current generation of North American farmers, little published research exists on forage production under such systems. Much of the work that has been done has been conducted on publicly owned research stations or in unreplicated studies on private farms. The work that has been published suggests that small to moderate sized livestock farms should be able to produce high quality forage at relatively low cost using rotational pasture management and that pasture forage can provide the bulk of the forage requirements of either dairy or beef animals. However, there is little documentation of these assumptions from private MIRG farms under farmer management. Productivity and forage quality of unmanaged, continuously grazed pastures has also not been well documented, despite the fact that there are literally millions of acres of such pastures in eastern North America. Study Description This research compared pasture growth and forage production and quality of rotationally and continuously grazed pastures. The study was conducted on three MIRG dairy farms and three continuously grazed pastures in southwestern Wisconsin in each of two years (1994 and 1995). Forage samples were collected from more than 100 acres of each pasture type weekly from early May through early October, so that both ready‐to‐graze and regrowing paddocks were sampled. Stock classes grazed on both rotational and continuous pastures included dry and lactating dairy cows and heifers. For MIRG farms, season‐long stocking rates averaged 1.34 animal units (AU) per acre with an average instantaneous stocking density of 24 AU/acre for both years. Time on paddock was based on forage mass as assessed by the farmer and varied from 12 h to 3 d. Season‐long stocking rate for continuously grazed pastures averaged 1.38 AU/acre in both years. With one exception, none of the pastures were fertilized with commercial fertilizer during the study. The single exception was one of the rotational farms, which applied 100 lb N/acre in a single application in early summer of 1994. Yield and quality following the application did not stand out from levels observed on other rotational pastures at the same time. Applied Questions Which system provided the highest level of forage availability? Forage mass was higher for ready‐to‐graze rotational paddocks than for continuously grazed pastures during every month of the growing season. For rotational paddocks, forage mass averaged 1763 lb/acre, whereas continuous pastures averaged only 850 lb/acre. The greatest differences in availability were in May and June, when rotational paddocks averaged nearly three times as much forage as continuous pastures. At equivalent levels of forage mass, which system provided the best forage quality? The MIRG farmers in our study grazed their paddocks at forage levels between 1300 and 1900 lb/acre. When we compared forage quality of ready‐to‐graze rotational paddocks with that of continuous pastures at similar levels, we found that rotational management combines greater forage mass with higher nutritional quality. For continuously grazed pastures, we observed an inverse linear relationship between forage mass and quality. As forage mass increased, crude protein levels decreased and ADF and NDF levels increased. How did growth, productivity, and forage quality of rotationally grazed pastures differ from continuously grazed pastures? Seasonal growth patterns in continuous and rotational pastures followed predictable curves with rotational pastures consistently out yielding continuously grazed pastures throughout the growing season. Forage crude protein and NDF levels were similar for rotational and continuous pastures in the early weeks of the growing season but differed after May, with rotational pastures tending to have higher protein levels and lower NDF levels than continuous pastures. Acid detergent fiber levels followed a similar curve for rotational and continuous pastures, rising to the upper 30s in midsummer and declining slightly in September. For continuous pastures, forage quality was inversely related to forage mass and declines in forage quality were predictable with increasing forage yields. For rotational pastures, crude protein declined with increasing forage mass but not as much as for continuous pastures, and ADF and NDF were not predictable for forage yields of 500 to 2000 lb/acre. Forage mass between 1300 and 1900 lb/acre appeared to provide a balance between yield and quality on rotationally managed pastures and cooperating farmers most often chose to graze paddocks at this level. Ready‐to‐graze MIRG paddocks had significantly higher quality than CON pastures at equivalent levels of forage biomass.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Paine et al. (1999) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: