Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
1412 DISEASES OF THE COLON & RECTUM VOLUME 62: 12 (2019) Patients diagnosed with cancer of the rectum face very difficult surgical decisions–whether to have a colostomy or a colorectal anastomosis. Despite significant advances in surgical techniques and improved oncologic outcomes, this decision is far from easy. Many patients can find the idea of a permanent colostomy untenable. On the other hand, other patients find that restorative reconstruction is associated with significantly impaired bowel function. Most will agree that patient preferences should play a major role to improve decision quality and minimize decisional regret for the treatment of colon and rectal cancer. However, there is very little evidence that patients are informed, involved, and understand the potential challenges that they face with both these surgical methods. In many clinical fields, the idea of shared decision-making and the use of patient decision aids have emerged to try and address this issue. Decision aids are evidence-based tools designed to help patients make informed choices by providing information on the pros, cons, risks, probabilities, and scientific uncertainty of available options before making a decision. Decision aids can be used when there are multiple reasonable options, when no single option has a clear advantage over the others in terms of health outcomes, or when each option has benefits and harms that patients value differently. By allowing patients to clarify and communicate the personal values that they associate with different treatment options, decision aids can improve the match between personal values and treatment choice. Studies have demonstrated that decision aids increase patient knowledge, reduce decisional conflict, help patients make appropriate decisions, and can have a positive effect on patient-clinician communication. We performed a comprehensive search on decision aids for colorectal cancer treatment. We found that the current literature evaluating decision aids for colorectal cancer treatment is sparse, with only 3 studies conducted, including 1 randomized controlled trial and 2 before-andafter studies. All 3 of the studies are of low quality and have significant risk of selection bias, reporting bias, and/ or performance bias because of a lack of control group and randomization. In the process of our review, however, we did find literature that is robust on the use of decision support tools, including decision aids for colorectal cancer screening options. In addition, there is unclear quality of some of the decision aids themselves used within these studies. Wu et al developed a decision aid using the well-recognized Ottawa framework for patient decision aids for patients facing the decision between low anterior resection and abdominoperineal resection, which they found effective at reducing decisional conflict and improving knowledge. Although Funding/Support: None reported.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Ivatury et al. (2019) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: