Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The Journal of Small Animal Practice is primarily aimed at providing relevant information for veterinarians in practice. However, a general practitioner cannot possibly keep up with the volume of information currently being published in veterinary medicine. The number of articles published in veterinary medicine has increased by 67% from 1996 to 2010, with the doubling rate of information in general sciences estimated at between 7 and 13 years. This is also reflected in the rise of specialisation, and even sub-specialisation, in veterinary medicine. As a result, one of the roles of periodicals such as the Journal of Small Animal Practice is to provide practitioners with information on new technologies and procedures for the purpose of making readers aware of these advancements, but not necessarily with the intention of implementing those advancements into their practice right away. There are many examples of how this can be beneficial for a general practitioner. For instance, there are numerous surgical procedures described for the correction of the cranial cruciate ligament-deficient stifle in dogs. A general practitioner should not be expected to have a detailed knowledge of all these procedures, but they should be expected to have a general knowledge of these techniques to provide their clientele with sufficient information to make informed decisions on the care of their pets. Similarly, there are a number of advancements being made in the field of surgical oncology, including sentinel lymph node mapping and the intraoperative assessment of surgical margins, such as described in this issue (Iida et al. 2013). The facilities, equipment and expertise required to perform intraoperative assessment of surgical margins is not feasible for the majority of general practices; however, a knowledge of this technology has the potential to significantly improve the outcome and decrease the morbidity, costs and anxiety for our patients with cancer and their owners. Currently, histopathology is the gold standard for assessment of surgical margins. The principal disadvantage of histopathology is that the knowledge of whether a tumour has been completely or incompletely excised is not known at the time of surgery. The local tumour recurrence rate in women following breast-conserving surgery is 5% following complete excision and 25% following incomplete or clean-but-close excisions. Similarly, local recurrence is 11-times more likely following incomplete resection in dogs with cutaneous soft-tissue sarcomas. If a tumour has been incompletely resected, then re-excision of the surgical scar is recommended to improve tumour control and survival outcomes. In breast-conserving surgery, re-excision rates following histopathological assessment of surgical margins are 25 to 35%. However, re-excision is also associated with an increase in morbidity, treatment costs and anxiety. In an effort to reduce re-excision rates in human oncology, intraoperative techniques of assessing surgical margins have been investigated. The most common intraoperative techniques used to assess surgical margins are frozen sections and imprint cytology. The re-excision rates following intraoperative assessment of margins using these techniques are 5 to 10%, which is a significant improvement compared to histopathology. These techniques are rarely used in veterinary medicine for logistical reasons, primarily because an experienced onsite pathologist is required for their interpretation. Furthermore, a commonly cited criticism of histopathology, frozen sections and imprint cytology is that these techniques assess tissue removed from the surgical site, but do not assess the presence and extent of tumour burden remaining at the surgical site following tumour resection. Research on margin assessment in human oncological surgery is currently focused on intraoperative, real-time, non-destructive techniques to rapidly assess the microscopic status of the surgical field. These real-time, intraoperative techniques include optical coherence tomography, radiofrequency spectroscopy, Raman spectroscopy, positron emission tomography probes and near-infrared fluorescence optical imaging. Near-infrared fluorescence optical imaging, an example of which is eloquently described by the authors in Intraoperative identification of canine hepatocellular carcinoma with indocyanine green fluorescent imaging (Iida et al. 2013), has proved most promising in research animals and dogs and humans with naturally occurring disease. While it is unreasonable to expect all readers to be familiar with the technical aspects of near-infrared fluorescence optical imaging or to use this technology in their practice, it is important to know the deficiencies of using histopathology for the assessment of surgical margins and that new and improved techniques for the intraoperative assessment of margins will become commonplace in referral and academic hospitals in the near future. Dr. Julius Liptak graduated from the University of Melbourne, completed a Residency in Small Animal Surgery at the University of Sydney, and Clinical and Research Fellowships in Surgical Oncology at the Animal Cancer Center at Colorado State University. He was a Professor in Small Animal Surgery at the Ontario Veterinary College in Canada prior to moving to his current position as specialist small animal surgeon at Alta Vista Animal Hospital in Ottawa, Canada. He has published over 50 papers on surgical oncology related topics in peer-reviewed veterinary and human journals, authored over 20 book chapters in veterinary surgery and oncology textbooks, and presented at numerous local, national and international conferences. Dr. Liptak was founding President of the Veterinary Society of Surgical Oncology and was awarded the Stephen J. Withrow Award for Advancing the Art and Science of Surgical Oncology in 2010. In 2012, he became an ACVS Founding Fellow in Surgical Oncology.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Julius M. Liptak (2013) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: