Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Background: Stereotactic radiosurgery (SRS) with a linear accelerator requires submillimetre geometric accuracy. The Winston–Lutz (WL) test verifies coincidence among radiation, mechanical, and imaging isocentres. While portal imaging (EPID)-based WL methods offer rapid assessments, results may depend on image quality, ball bearing (BB) size, field size, and software algorithms. Aim: To systematically compare commercial and open-source WL analysis software under varying imaging conditions. Setting: Multiple radiotherapy centres across Western Cape South Africa. Utilizing Varian Trilogy and Elekta Versa HD linear accelerators. Methods: Megavoltage (MV) EPID images were acquired on a Varian Trilogy (150 cm SID) and Elekta VersaHD (160 cm SID) using 6 MV flattened beams across multiple gantry and couch angles. Field sizes 10 cm × 10 cm, 6 cm × 6 cm and 2 cm × 2 cm and BB diameters 8 mm, 5 mm and 3 mm were tested. Images were analysed using Physikalisch-Technische Werkstätten (PTW) IsoCheck v1.2, SNC Machine v2.0.6, DoseLab Pro v7.0.0, PIPSpro Stereotactic v5.0.0, and PyLinac v2.2.6. Evaluated metrics included maximum total delta, 3D isocentre displacement, and isocentre diameter. Results: Processing success and accuracy varied by BB size, field size, and linac type. Most software failed on Elekta VersaHD images with a 3 mm BB, except DoseLab, which succeeded in all cases. On Trilogy, smaller fields yielded smaller deltas; the inverse occurred on VersaHD (neither trend was statistically significant). SNC Machine exhibited the largest delta variation (Coefficient of Variation [CoV]: 19% – 114%), while DoseLab was most consistent (CoV: 1% – 6%). IsoCheck and PyLinac yielded comparable isocentre diameters when processing succeeded, with optimal consistency at 5 mm BB (Trilogy) and 8 mm BB (VersaHD). Conclusion: The WL test outcomes depend on software, BB size, and imaging geometry. Preprocessing flexibility enhances robustness, and using larger BBs (5 mm – 8 mm) and mid-sized fields (~6 cm × 6 cm) improves detectability. When the 3D isocentre shift is minimised, maximum total delta can reflect the isocentre target error, but understanding software-specific definitions remains critical for SRS quality assurance (QA). Contribution: This study compares the performance of different WL software when analysing the same images.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Fourie et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: