Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
From the Department of Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery at Groote Schuur Hospital and the University of Cape Town. Received for publication December 30, 1999; revised February 28, 2000. Plastic surgery is undergoing another quiet revolution—not so much in new techniques and technology, although these are occurring, but in concepts and understanding of the effect these newer technologies are having on human tissue. For decades, plastic surgery, especially cosmetic surgery, was concerned essentially with dealing with “excess” tissue. Because the fundamental working tissue of the plastic surgeon was the skin, the focus of the specialty was developing methods of removing excess skin. In a sense, this is illustrated by the traditional subcutaneous rhytidectomy, in which skin undermining was extended further and further. No other method was considered to exist to deal with the excess. However, the development of newer techniques (e.g., liposuction, endoscopic surgery) and the availability of botulinum toxin have led plastic surgeons to re-examine their methods of dealing with the “excess” and have questioned the dogma of focusing on the skin to achieve results. In fact, newer concepts regarding skin mechanics have evolved as a result of these techniques; they have demonstrated that surface changes may be effected by methods other than simple or sophisticated skin excision. Whereas these concepts have been alluded to in the plastic surgery literature, this editorial attempts to highlight these concepts and to provide a composite picture for reflection and consideration. Concept 1: Skin Excess Is Treated by Excision (Old Concept) versus Skin Excess Can Be Dealt with by Redraping (New Concept) Traditionally the focus of the discipline has been the skin. Excess skin is simply excised, albeit in a sophisticated way. For example, in the aging face, excess skin led to folds or jowls—this was dealt with by a subcutaneous rhytidectomy. Similarly, in an approach to reduction mammaplasty, the focus of the Wise keyhole or inverted-T pattern is on the skin; reduction and improved shape are obtained by tightening the skin envelope. The parenchyma is not considered in this approach. In contrast, newer techniques do not just excise skin excess; rather, tissue is molded (see concept 2) and the skin is redraped over the sculpted parenchyma. In part, this paradigm shift has evolved from liposuction, where it is well established that skin retraction occurs if the tissue beneath it (i.e., the fat) is removed—no skin needs to be excised. An extension of this concept is demonstrated by skin redraping, which is observed after undermining in a deep-tissue plane. In the endoscopic forehead lift, for example, little or no skin is excised, but rather the skin is redraped to achieve a more youthful appearance. It is important to be aware that there are limitations to the amount of skin that can be redraped; hence, this concept is applicable only where there is not a large amount of skin laxity. In the latter situation, redraping will be an inadequate form of treatment, and of course excision is the better option. Clinically one is now required not only to carefully assess the quantity of excess skin but also to pay equal attention to its quality. It is this factor that determines the capacity to redrape. Simplistically it is determined by three major factors—age, genes, and anatomic site—and a host of minor factors including skin type, smoking habits, and body weight fluctuations. Concept 2: Alteration to the Surface Anatomy Can Be Achieved by Molding and Repositioning the Parenchyma 1 It has now recognized that SMAS manipulation (or some method of deep-tissue manipulation) in rhytidectomy produces better and longer-lasting results. It is also acknowledged that skin tightening in rhytidectomy can flatten the facial contour 2 and lead to an “ operated look.” Skin is meant to serve as a covering function, 2 not a supporting one, and it has been suggested that with adequate deep-tissue support, the skin should simply be approximated without any tension. 2 Similarly, in “traditional” techniques of lower lid blepharoplasty, the skin, muscle, and fat were considered to represent “excess” as a result of aging and were excised. More recently, it has been suggested that better results might be achieved by repositioning the fat rather than excising it. 3 The repositioning of the fat (the parenchyma) obviously has an impact on the surface of the skin. The same principles can be applied when dealing with the orbicularis oculi muscle. Note that external support, strapping, taping, and pressure garments play an important role in sculpting and remolding tissue. This is a field that requires further investigation by rigorous scientific study. Concept 3: Changes to Surface Anatomy Can Be Affected by Alterations of Muscle Vectors All muscle action is the result of a synchronous interaction between agonists and antagonists. Although muscle is “deeply” situated tissue, it is now recognized that changing the dynamic interaction between different muscle vectors—with botulinum toxin, 4 for example—has a direct effect on the surface anatomy. In the forehead, paralyzing the forehead depressors with Botox leads to a muscle imbalance. This allows the forehead elevators to assume a relative increase in muscle power with an attendant beneficial effect on the forehead and eyebrows. The benefits are not restricted to cosmetic surgery. In a preliminary report, 5 a small dose of Botox used after flexor tendon repair weakened the tendon sufficiently to prevent rupture but allowed sufficient strength for active mobilization to occur, with its attendant benefits on tendon healing. Concept 4: The Minus/Plus Concept This concept is especially applicable to cosmetic surgery. The concept was initially proposed by Regnault et al. 6 in regard to mastopexy. They recognized that simple mastopexy was often an inadequate procedure for the aging, drooping breast. In addition to a pexy, it also required augmentation to provide a fuller, more natural look. This concept has also been applied to the aging face, where soft-tissue augmentation can be combined with skin excision to yield a more favorable result. In the technique described by Guerrerosantos, fat may be added to the zygoma but removed from the neck. 7 Concept 5: New Creases and Folds Can Also Be Created Surprisingly, there is still a lot of debate as to exactly what constitutes the common folds in the body, especially the nasolabial fold and the inframammary fold or crease. A common theory holds that a dermal ligament attaches the skin to deeper tissue (muscle). Skin is a dynamic structure. It can stretch and expand, as shown by pregnancy and tissue expansion; this can occur in a serial manner as well. Similarly, skin can retract and recoil. Techniques currently in use can create folds and creases. In the short scar techniques of breast reduction, a new inframammary fold is created. 1 Similarly, an iatrogenic fold can be created by injudicious liposuctioning of the posterior thigh, leading to the banana-roll deformity. This concept is at present not widely employed in plastic surgery, but as our understanding of the dynamics of skin evolves, it might be used more frequently. Summary Methods of dealing with the parenchyma now seem to be much more important than was the case previously. The skin is considered secondarily. This is evident in the plethora of new techniques for rhytidectomy. These newer techniques all manipulate the deeper tissue in different ways. The large number of different techniques described indicates just how many ways the deep tissue can be manipulated. In addition, there are other methods to effect change in the surface topography, for example, by altering the balance of muscle vectors. These factors have altered the way plastic surgeons assess and manage clinical problems, and in many instances this has led to improved results.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Donald Anthony Hudson (2000) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: