Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Extending historical records into the present offers a powerful opportunity to examine how bird phenology is shifting in response to warming temperatures and whether those responses are consistent over time. In Concord, Massachusetts (USA), a uniquely rich record of bird migration phenology dates back to the mid-19th century, beginning with observations made by the American philosopher Henry David Thoreau (1851–1854), and continuing with well-known ornithologists William Brewster (1886–1919) and Ludlow Griscom (1930–1954), and schoolteacher Rosita Corey (1956–2007). A previous analysis of these records had shown that on average migratory birds were not changing their arrival times over this 156 year period, contrasting with rapid changes in plant phenology. To extend these bird arrival records and assess recent changes, we combined historical observations of first arrival dates for 18 bird species with observations submitted to the online platform eBird between 2013–2024 in Concord, Massachusetts. Using a subset of eBird data to approximate historical sampling effort, we found that, on average, birds are arriving about 7 days earlier now than in the past, reflecting a stronger response to warming temperatures and shifts in the phenology of more species than observed in our previous study. The rate of change in bird phenology appears to be catching up to changes in plant leaf-out and flowering phenology observed in Concord (~10–14 days earlier now than in Thoreau’s time). This study shows that the rate of phenological response to climate change can vary over time and demonstrates methods for combining historical data with modern citizen science data to assess these changes and their potential ecological impacts.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Gallinat et al. (2025) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: