Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Background and objective Inter- and transdisciplinary (ITD) health research is increasingly promoted as a way of addressing complex problems, yet collaboration remains shaped by epistemic, social and institutional tensions. This article examines the ethical and collaborative effects of a scientific facilitation intervention, the Toolbox Dialogue Initiative (TDI), implemented in an interdisciplinary clinical research team in Québec. Methods We conducted a qualitative case study of a nine-member clinical research team studying the effects of manual therapies on the vagus nerve. The intervention combined a philosophical instrument-questionnaire with a facilitated dialogue workshop. Its evaluation drew on process evaluation and program theory to distinguish individual-level mechanisms (reflexivity, perspective-taking) from group-level outcomes (mutual understanding, socio-cognitive integration). Data were collected through participant observation, pre- and post-intervention questionnaires, and semi-structured interviews, and analysed using inductive thematic coding and triangulation. Results TDI acted as a catalyst for reflexivity by making tacit epistemic divergences visible and fostering mutual understanding within the team. However, these mechanisms did not translate into sustained socio-cognitive integration: the research object was ultimately recentred according to a dominant disciplinary framing, and the absence of follow-up limited the intervention’s long-term effects. Although participants reported a positive workshop experience overall, the patient partner described feeling vulnerable and “under scrutiny”, suggesting that procedural fairness and psychological safety were unevenly achieved. Conclusion TDI illustrates both the promise and the ambivalence of scientific facilitation in health research. It can support epistemic justice and shared reflexivity, but its effects remain fragile when facilitation is conceived as a one-off, peripheral activity. Scientific facilitation should therefore be understood as a situated professional and ethical practice, embedded in project governance and supported by sustained reflexive work.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
B. Hogedez (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: