Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
“The most common complication associated with rhytidectomy is hematoma. . . . The prevention of this complication is absolute hemostasis.” 1 Since Baker and Gordon wrote these statements in their pioneering article in 1967, many authors have studied this issue, debating its pathophysiology and searching for an effective way to prevent its occurrence. We welcome the present contribution by Drs Ballan and Jabbour and their co-authors, in which they offer a thorough review of the different quilting suture methods described.2 Their work will certainly serve as a very good reference for those who already employ them as well as for those who plan to start utilizing this technique. Internal quilting sutures are a simple surgical tactic as demonstrated by Baroudi and Ferreira in 1993.3 Their principles are based on “elimination of dead space, broad distribution of wound tension, and the facilitation of healing of 2 raw surfaces by suture fixation,” as pointed out by Pollock and Pollock.4 In facelifts, internal and external quilting sutures were initially described as a way of limiting dead space, favoring flap stabilization and the healing process as demonstrated by Hudson and Pontes,5,6 but not as a method to prevent hematomas. In 2012, we published the first series of patients, to our knowledge, in which external quilting sutures were employed for the prevention of such complication in rhytidectomies.7 This primary goal, associated with the external aspect of the suture (a “fishing net”), led us to call this tactic the “hemostatic net.” Since then, it has been successfully utilized as an effective way to avoid postoperative bleeding. Grover et al employed a multivariate analysis to understand the different causes leading to hematoma.8 They concluded that anterior platysmaplasty is the strongest factor associated with it, followed by preoperative systolic pressure >150 mmHg, male gender, aspirin or nonsteroidal antiinflammatory intake, and smoking. These findings indicate that the larger the detached surface, the higher the likelihood of bleeding. Unfortunately, most studies about complications in facelifts do not consider the amplitude of dissection as a variable, and comparing them leads to limited conclusions. In any case, as the authors well conclude, eliminating dead spaces underscores the potential positive role of quilting sutures. In the early 2000s, as we experienced an increase in the number of rhytidectomies associated with platysmaplasty in our practice, we were confronted with the challenges of a proportionately increased number of hematomas despite our efforts to curb them. Thompson and Ashley9 described the frustration with the different tactics for prevention: “Many methods for avoiding or minimizing this complication have been advocated. . . . At one time or another we have tried almost all of these gimmicks—with no conclusive benefit.” Some of these hematomas we encountered in our practice were treated with aspiration and the placement of transdermal stitches to forcefully and mechanically stop the bleeding. Sutures were kept for 48 hours with no flap ischemia or healing problems observed. These results encouraged us to utilize the tactic to avoid hematomas. That is how the hemostatic net was born: from a successful method to treat to an effective strategy to prevent hematomas. Some technical aspects should be observed to reach absolute hematoma prevention with the hemostatic net. A supplementary video illustrates the most important steps during a hemostatic net facelift. In our experience, applying internal stitches is technically more difficult, especially when the neck is open through a submental incision, ultimately providing an incomplete closure of all dead spaces. Expansive medium-size hematomas could form in these areas, requiring surgical drainage. Smaller hematic collections may also occur and not be diagnosed, leading to “unsightly lumps” or permanent visible “skin contracture,” as indicated by Rees.10 A basic principle of the hemostatic net is that all areas must be meticulously closed, leaving virtually no space for blood to collect. Since our first case of hemostatic net for the prevention of hematomas in rhytidectomies in 2010, we have employed this tactic in 1231 consecutive patients (1132 women [92%] and 99 men [8%]). We have not encountered any hematomas while the net is kept in place, normally for 48 hours. We had 7 hematomas after the removal of the net (4 men and 3 women). These were related to restlessness, which led to the detachment of the flap from the superficial muscular aponeurotic system (SMAS)-platysma, nausea and vomiting, and hypertension. Treatment with aspiration and application of another hemostatic net resolved these cases. Punctiform lesions left by the net heal inconspicuously in the majority of patients. In our first report, we used nylon 4-0 and observed some hypopigmentation (1.2%) and transient hyperpigmentation (17.1%).11 These rates have been significantly lowered in the last years, possibly due to the utilization of nylon 5-0. Because of the ethnic composition in our region, most patients are Fitzpatrick skin types 1 to 4. Our experience with patients types 5 and 6, although limited, has not indicated healing problems. Leaving the net for more than 48 hours (3 or 4 days) is an alternative that we reserve for specific conditions, among them male patients, restlessness, nausea, vomiting, hypertension, surgeries performed just before weekends or holidays, poor compliance with medical directions, and use of anticoagulants. Some colleagues have personally reported that they routinely keep the net for more than 48 hours. That is the case with Dr Daniel Labbé (Caen, France, personal communication), who removes it on the fourth postoperative day with no healing adversities. In a dramatic case reported to us by Dr Jean-Paul Meningaud (Paris, France), a patient who underwent facelift with the hemostatic net developed myocardial infarction at the end of surgery and was promptly treated with fibrinolytic therapy and anticoagulation. The net was kept for 4 days with no hematomas. Eventually there was full recovery from the cardiac condition. Removal of the hemostatic net is simple and straightforward, as in any external skin suture. All loops of the suture should be removed. As a consequence, no long-lasting dimples in skin are seen with the hemostatic net, an observation reported with internal quilting sutures. Inflammatory reactions to the stitches are also minimal compared with absorbable sutures. We have previously demonstrated that the hemostatic net does not increase the incidence of flap ischemia and necrosis.11 This clinical observation is shared by Dr T. G. O’Daniel (Louisville, KY).12 In fact, capillary refill and thermography mapping before and after dissection, and after the hemostatic net is applied, show adequate flap perfusion (A.A. and L.A.A., unpublished data). If any doubt about blood circulation remains after the net is placed, sutures should be removed. Dr Jared Little of the University of Kentucky performed laser angiography utilizing the SPY System (LifeCell Corp., Branchburg, NJ) in a patient who had a large cervical flap for reconstruction after a melanoma resection. Measures of perfusion before and after the hemostatic net showed no significant reduction (89% and 85%, respectively).12 A larger series of hemostatic net patients mapped with laser angiography is currently being studied by Drs O’Daniel and Little in the hopes that it will add interesting information about flap circulation. In the early stages of the technique, we were concerned about lesions of the motor and sensitive facial nerves due to the passage of the needle when applying the net. However, we have not observed an increase in such complications. The hemostatic net encompasses the superficial portion of the SMAS-platysma, avoiding the subfascial aspect where the nerves are found. In fact, plication, dissection, and resection of the SMAS-platysma are performed in a much more aggressive manner compared with the net. In addition, the 5-0 nylon is a relatively delicate suture, employed with light tension. Time has also shown that bleeding from the external jugular vein does not occur with the hemostatic net, possibly because its running fashion ensures hemostatic control. Two other issues that we have considered when utilizing the hemostatic net are the time and cost to perform it. In the pre-net era, we formerly spent 20 to 30 minutes with electrocautery hemostasis of each side of the face. Today, this time was compacted to 2 to 3 minutes, because only major bleeders are coagulated. Minor ones are controlled with the net while the blood is aspirated with a Yankauer suction tip device. The average time to apply the net in each side is about 15 minutes. The healing process is greatly improved because the residual thermal damage, and consequently edema, are significantly reduced. The cost of about twenty 5-0 nylon sutures employed in a hemostatic net facelift is considerably attractive if one considers the advantage of not utilizing drains, possible early discharge, and the absolute control of bleeding with no returns to the operating room to treat a hematoma. Since our first cases performed with the hemostatic net, we have observed that skin redraping became a much easier and predictable task. This has been particularly important in patients with severe dermal laxity. Extending dissection down to the lower neck—with no hematomas—has significantly improved our cervicoplasty results. Furthermore, the employment of the net has been expanded by other colleagues for reconstructive and aesthetical purposes. Drs Fausto Viterbo (Botucatu, Brazil), Gerry O’Daniel, and Ozan Sozer (El Paso, TX) have popularized the gliding brow lift, a technique that employs the hemostatic net principles.13 The review by Drs Ballan and Jabbour and their collaborators helps to further establish the role of quilting sutures in limiting dead space and favoring more predictable outcomes in facelifts. After almost 10 years of utilizing the hemostatic net, we continue to concur with Baker and Gordon: “prevention of this complication is absolute hemostasis,” an objective the net efficiently delivers. However, with more than 1200 patients and no bleeding in the first 48 hours after surgery, we can no longer say that “the most common complication associated with rhytidectomy is hematoma.” This article contains supplementary material located online at www.aestheticsurgeryjournal.com. Watch now at http://academic.oup.com/asj/article-lookup/doi/10.1093/asj/sjaa014 The authors declared no potential conflicts of interest with respect to the research, authorship, and publication of this article. The authors received no financial support for the research, authorship, and publication of this article.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Auersvald et al. (2020) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: